4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
#1 Turbomachinery Textbook (spoiled by poor manufacturing quality), May 2, 2010
This review is from: Design of High-Efficiency Turbomachinery and Gas Turbines, The (2nd Edition) (Paperback)
This is the #1 turbomachinery textbook, written by a very respectable author and professor from MIT, the #1 engineering institution in the world. It is the only text out there with a nice unified theory, and it is ripe with very good examples. The theories in this texbook will give you an excellent understanding of how turbomachines work --- all without requiring the use of MATLAB or FORTRAN (actually doing the hand calculations will make you understand what MATLAB/FORTRAN/NPSS simulations are doing).
There is one major technical issue with the physical book itself. The paperback version of this book is a complete nightmare. Within 2 weeks of using this for our turbomachinery class at the Air Force Institute of Technology, the book simply fell apart due to a poorly manufactured binder. The first real problem that occurs when you open this text is that it is impossible to keep it open without suspending a huge paperweight over it (even when opened in the middle of the book). Once you "break in" the book, the pages simply fall out. I'm not the only one with this problem. Many others in the class with me have this exact issue.
- In my previous review, I'd mentioned that the diagrams and figures are tough to read. This is because the publisher prints the book at awful resolutions, making the diagrams (especially the Mellor charts) tough to read.
- As a minor suggestion, some of the figures could be labeled a little more. For example, in chapter 2, problem #9, (figure P2.9 on page 91) we are given a radial turbine problem with a very good description of the dimensions, but it was tough to match the words in the problem statement to the those dimensions (i.e.; "the axial height of the blade passage is ten percent of the rotor diameter").
- The publisher is really to blame for the serious quality issues of the paperback version of this text (which, right now, is the only one you can get for the 2nd edition). The author of the text himself has gone after Prentice Hall/Pierson on several occasions, and yet the problem persists.
AMAZON: I would suggest you gripe at the publisher to produce better quality books. No one should ever pay that much for a textbook only to have it fall apart in less than 3 weeks.
PIERSON: Selling brand new textbooks that fall apart after three weeks of normal use is what I would consider an unacceptable business practice. You need to focus your efforts on quaity, and actually listen to the author when he says to fix the problems, instead of worrying about your profit margins. Engineering textbooks like this one are used by people who are involved in the actual design of things -- in this case, turbomachinery (i.e.; jet engines--those things sitting on an airplane wing that make it go). Quality CANNOT be compromised.
The book itself clearly deserves a 5-star rating; Pierson really needs to fix the problems with the paperback version.
If you're interested in designing turbomachinery, there is NO OTHER textbook like this one (I have looked at others; nothing else comes close). Just keep in mind that if you purchase this one, pages in chapters 5-7 will start to fall out. The author is currently working on making an electronic book available for us; if that happens, I'm buying that one immediately (and I would suggest you do the same).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The best gas turbine design textbook, hands down, November 17, 2010
This review is from: Design of High-Efficiency Turbomachinery and Gas Turbines, The (2nd Edition) (Paperback)
I design turbine engines for a living, and I own many gas turbine textbooks: Cohen/Rogers/Saravanamuttoo; Walsh and Fletcher; Sawyer's; Boyce; Japikse et al.; Bathie; Davey.
Wilson's book is the best by far. The text approaches the subject in a design-centric, vs. analysis-centric, way, making it much more interesting, approachable, and useful. It covers all key aspects of engine design - thermodynamics, aerodynamics, structures, materials, combustion, heat transfer - but it does not overwhelm you with too many minutiae. Wilson provides historical examples to bring to illustrate the equations, breathing life into them. Most textbooks give you knowledge of a subject; this one gives you an *understanding*.
I agree with the previous review, particularly on the quality of the binding - terrible. The same was true of the hardback version. However, don't let that stop you from ordering it. I'd rather have a falling-apart copy of Wilson than a structurally sound copy of any other gas turbine textbook, hands down.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No