Customer Reviews

TBD Devastator Units of the US Navy (Osprey Combat Aircraft 20)

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I've read 3 books that review the history of the TBD in the U.S. Navy, and got the same general feeling from them all: why is this book so short? We're talking about the first monoplane that was ever accepted by the Navy for service, and was a major contributor to pre-war naval aviation's attack doctrine. Further, the sacrifices made by the aircrew who flew the TBD in combat through June 1942 deserves volumes written about them to help us remember what happened.

Barrett Tillman's book is very good, but I feel the subject deserves a larger work. I was impressed with the photos of men like Lem Massey, Gene Lindsey, Art Ely, and etc., but seeing them brought this feeling up in me all the more.

I do recommend Mr. Tillman's book as an excellent effort overall- many people may feel as if my complaints about the shortness of an otherwise fine work is nothing more than a quibble- but I do feel the subject is worthy of the extra effort.

This book is a must for anyone interested in the history of aviation during World War 2. The men that operated the TBD Devastators are fine examples of heroes. Mr. Tillman's brilliant book need be given high honors for the rememberance of these brave souls and the mark that these Navy torpdeo planes have left in history. To the memory of Torpedo squadrons who fought at the Battle Of Coral Sea and Midway. You brave souls are on eteranl patrol and this book (as well as Mr. Tillman)gives us the opportunity to get to know you and the TBD Devastator.

Never received this item from seller, The Book Depository, New Jersey.

Received email that book was sent 2 days after order with expected arrival date.

Date came and went, Contacted seller and they gave me a different ship date than

orginally. Still Have not received Book and recieved refund from seller and purchased through Amazon.com direct for slightly more, but don't regret paying more now.