Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
"Ignorance is not the same as insanity.", April 13, 2005
This review is from: The Devil of Nanking: A Novel (Hardcover)
A disturbed, young British woman, known only as Grey, arrives in Tokyo after a long hospitalization in a psychiatric unit. She has been hoping for nine years to find a piece of film recording the Nanking Massacre in China by the Japanese in 1937, a massacre of 300,000 people, which the Japanese deny happened. Needing a very specific bit of information that she believes is in the film, Grey contacts Shi Chongming, an elderly Chinese professor at a Japanese university, whom she believes has the missing film. She eventually agrees to try to unearth information he wants about a life-saving medicine used by an ailing Japanese gangster in exchange for information about the Nanking film.
Grey is a fragile and interesting character, bearing both physical and emotional scars, and when she is accepted as a hostess at the "Some Like it Hot" nightclub, run by the unforgettable Strawberry Nakatani, who believes herself a Marilyn Monroe look-alike, she meets the ailing gangster, Junzo Fuyuki. Other intriguing peripheral characters add to the drama: Jason, an American with a pre-occupation with death and a sexual fetish for "weirdos" like Grey; a pair of Russian twins, who are also hostesses; and Ogawa, the transvestite nurse of the gangster, who lurks in the background and acts as an enforcer. The various settings, especially that of a falling-down house occupied by Grey, Jason, and the Russian twins, showcase the bizarre characters and their actions.
The point of view alternates between Grey, as she tries to gain control of her life by finding this mysterious film, and that of Shi Chongming, who recounts in painful detail his memories of the Japanese invasion of Nanking and the attempts that he and his wife Shujing make to to stay alive. The author's ability to present both internal action and external terror is admirable, creating both tension and heart-stopping suspense, though she does resort to obvious foreshadowing to keep the reader going: "I knew that the answer I wanted was very nearby," for example, and "I was sure, without knowing why, that just behind those blinds...."
The plot and characters are intriguing for the first two-thirds of the book. Then, as the exact nature of Grey's quest on behalf of Shi Chongming becomes clearer, the plot veers into stomach-turning sadism and perversion. Sensational deaths and ankle-deep gore increase as Grey's shocking "crime," Fuyuki's pathology, and Shi Chongming's "sin" come together in dramatic fashion. Not for the faint of heart, this pop novel is nightmare-inducing, filled with pathological behavior and grotesque deaths, minutely described. (3.5 stars). Mary Whipple
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A well written, slightly off beat drama/detective story, March 27, 2005
This review is from: The Devil of Nanking: A Novel (Hardcover)
"The Devil of Nanking", published as "Toyko" in some countries, is not your typical novel. For a start, the heroine is flawed with some mental and physical scars. Grey, the heroine, is obsessed with finding a film on which horrific footage of the Nanking massacres exist. As we find out during the course of the book, for Grey this is a particularly personal quest.
During her efforts to find and view the film, we are taken through 1990 Tokyo, with a well written cast. Jason the weird guy, the Russian girls, the Chinese professor who witnessed the crimes perpetrated in Nanking, and a mysterious Japanese gangster and his "Nurse", although only a couple of these are sketched out in great detail. The author isn't afraid to leave certain elements and characters of the story relatively vague, which makes for a more mysterious and dark feel to the story.
"The Devil of Nanking" is very well written, the author brings to life both the bright lights of 1990 Tokyo (her own experiences of night clubs in Tokyo no doubt proved useful material to draw upon in the writing of this novel) as well as the desperate dark period of December 1937 in Nanking. At the conclusion of the book, despite the revelation of what is revealed on the film (which I actually thought was fairly well signposted) Grey seeks and ultimately finds, you are left in an almost contemplative mood. I haven't read many books that have left me like that.
I don't normally read fiction, but I have developed a fascination with East Asia, having lived in Korea and visited both Japan and China, which attracted me to the book. I was not disappointed. The Devil of Nanking is defintely worth a read. Highly recommended, especially if you like more unusual novels and settings.
Postscript: If you are after some historical background information to the Nanking massacre, I recommend "The Rape of Nanking" by Iris Chang for a well written but controversial account (judging from the number of reviews for the book on Amazon) of the horrors that occurred in Nanking December 1937.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Horrible Yet Fascinating, April 24, 2005
This review is from: The Devil of Nanking: A Novel (Hardcover)
Mo Hayder does not have much in the way of formal schooling, but she has become an accomplished storyteller with a better-than-average writing skill. This novel is comprised of two stories intertwined to make a shocking whole. First and foremost, Hayder provides a realistic and accurate picture of what the IJA's (Imperial Japanese Army) destruction of Nanking, China must have been like.
Then the second story: Gray is a young woman who grew up only reading books--her parents did not have a television, nor were there other young people around while Gray was a child. She was reared on books; and somehow, a rare and terrifying account of Japan's genocide in Nanking comes under her intelligent adolescent scrutiny.
She becomes obsessed with viewing a film that shows torture and murder perpetuated by a perverse monster in the IJA--the Devil of Nanking. She finds help in Tokyo from the elderly man who brought the film back from China back in late 1937. Eventually, we as readers get the portrayal of Nanking's destruction through snippets from the elderly man's journal as well as by information Gray gleans while privately investigating as a "hostess" in a Tokyo nightclub.
This was well worth reading. I miss Jack Cafferty, the detective who stars in her first two novels (Birdman and Treatment) but Mo Hayder is not an author to be ignored. Her works are shocking and unique, and they deserve attention from anyone with the courage to stomach their contents.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|