Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Lacking Biting Wit, Sparkling Dialogue, and Narrative Sense, August 4, 2007
Why do Adrian and Emma "love" each other? after finishing "The Devilish Pleasures of a Duke" I have no true understanding why or how they fell in "love." There really only seems to be lust between the two, a physicalness, they very rarely speak of anything else than their physical attraction to each other, their encounters are completely limited to fondling and the like. There is no narrative meat to the text. It lacks the wit and banter of Hunter's other works. It is the wit and banter that make the reading of her earlier works in this series so much fun.
The lack that is felt between the two characters is held together by her family and their watchfulness, for a romance novel to focus so much on the family of guard dogs that the Boscastle brothers are relegated to, aptly demonstrates the disconnect between Emma, Adrian, and the character/narrative arc. The text goes nowhere from start to end because it is completely nonsensical how these two came together to find "love."
There is no frothy fun to be found in this text.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The last Bocastle hurrah went out with a sizzle, not a bang, August 17, 2007
I sincerely hope that Emma's tale is not the final note in the Bocaslte ledgers, not for the fact that i loved this story but more so that Ms Hunter will have a chance to redeem herself. Perhaps it's because I'm a picky reader, I can not stand it when the hero and heroines have past loves. Emma was a less than thrilling heroine, rather boring which left poor Adrian to pick up the slack. I felt that Emma and Adrian's relationship could have played out as a "b" line in another Bocastle story.
Though the love scenes were steamy, I was far more interested in the sub characters of Harriet the street smart urchin who had far more emotional depth than Emma, and of Lord Gabriel Bocastle the former outcast who's dark past is only hinted at.
I would also have liked for her to sum up more of the other Bocastle's lives if this was indeed the end.
So, pretty quick read, hot love scenes but nothing more than fluff
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not what I had hoped for, August 6, 2007
Having read the other books in this series, I was anxiously waiting for this one to be released. Both the hero and heroine have been featured as background characters in the earlier books of this series. Emma, a recurring character in all of the previous books, could always be counted on to be the epitome of prim and proper. To have her radically depart from what has always been the very essence of her being and behave as all of the Boscastles before her just didn't ring true for me. Maybe if I hadn't read the earlier books, I wouldn't have had believability issues with the newly sensuous Emma, but I just couldn't help but thinking that maybe it is time for the author, who is one of my favorites, to begin a new series and leave the beloved Boscastles behind.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|