Customer Reviews

Die Walkure

5 star:		(8)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

I am very glad to see the complimentary reviews on this recording. I am a member of the Met Orchestra and found it thrilling to record Die Walkuere with this cast and Levine. I am very surprised that nobody mentioned Kurt Moll as Hunding. It was the most amazing singing I ever heard. I would shiver as soon as he opened his mouth, such a menacing other-worldly sound. Unlike many singers who make several takes and some who go over and over their high notes, Mr. Moll recorded everything on the first take, one time and one time only.

People have criticized James Levine for his plodding tempos in his Wagner conducting. However, I believe that his conducting is most true to Wagner's score. I personally think that this Walkure is the best on disc, exceeding the recordings made by Sir Georg Solti, Herbert von Karajan, Clemens Krauss, and to a certain extent, Karl Böhm. The clear, precise, yet transparent sounds he draws from the Met Orchestra is superb, and he displays the psychological drama of the epic tetralogy to a tee. Dare I say that no other orchestra captures the soundscape of the Ring so clearly and beautifully as the Met does in this recording? The cast is top notch too, with Brunhildde being played by the very youthful sounding Hildegard Behrens in her prime. From the magnificent opening Hojotohos to her farewell with Wotan, none of the dramatic qualities of the part were missed by this gifted German soprano. You have here the feminine qualities perfected by Regine Crespin in her Karajan recording, plus the clarion high notes of Birgit Nilsson, and you have a great Valkyrie. Wotan is played by none other than James Morris, a singer whose Wotan I believe exceeds that of Hans Hotter in the Solti recording. This isn't a Wotan to fear, although that is one of the attributed the great American bass baritone can bring to the music. You also have Wotan the father, the lover, the compassionate head god who is distraught because he no longer has the universe under his control. A reference performance indeed. Gary Lakes plays Siegmund, a part bettered only by James King and Jon Vickers. His Sieglinde is Jessye Norman, and despite this talk about her overmannered Sieglinde, I would say that this is one of her greatest Wagner performances...very touching and vocally magnificent. Christa Ludwig plays Fricka, and although the voice is no longer what it was years ago for Solti, the drama she exudes in the text simply cuts through everything like a knife. This is a reference Fricka that must be held beside the hallmark one she recorded decades earlier for Solti. Finally, Hunding is played by none other than Kurt Moll. I wonder why this singer is cast so sparsely in other recordings when he can command some of the greatest Wagner performances on disc. His Gurnemanz, in my opinion, is the most wonderful in the discography if Hotter were erased from history's annals. The Valkyries are a finely tuned octet of sisters.

This truly is a great recording, and the sound is a miracle beyond miracles. Highly recommended!

I have seen three cycles of "The Ring" at the Met, and have tickets for the 2000 performances. I thought that James Levine was at his best in this opera. I also thought that I had never heard the music played so beautifully by an orchestra; the Met orchestra truthfully matched a performance I saw at Bayreuth in 1997. Therefore, I bought the Met-Levine "Walkure," knowing the strengths and weaknesses of the cast. I have not been disappointed. The orchestra sounds exhilerating on the CD's, Levine shapes the performances beautifully, and the musicianship and involvement of the cast is complete. In Act I, the music is plainly exciting and the singing noble. Some critics may question Behrens' voice in this opera and the two subsequent ones, but I have always found her a fine Brunnhilde who consistently gives 100% of herself to the performance. Morris' voice is magnificent, and the final "Abschied" is breathtaking. (As a matter of fact, it was this Brunnhilde-Wotan duet that curators chose to play at Wagner's home, Wahnfried, in Bayreuth for visitors. I may add that it sounded marvelous in Richard Wagner's living room.)Yes, I would highly recommend this recording as probably the most satisfactory recording of the opera. The Solti "Walkure" has many weaknesses, particularly in the first act, and with Hans Hotter who is too old for Wotan. I always thought that Solti's conducting of this opera was not his best, although I find his renditions of the other three "Ring" operas to be as close to definitive as one can get. I might add that the CD performance of "Die Walkure" is very different from the video performance, and much better. Act I of the video peformance tends to be mannered, particularly with Jessye Norman. Behrens is not in as good a voice as on the CD's. However, there is a great deal of excitement in the performance. I have not, as yet, mentioned Christa Ludwig, but her performance in Act II is one reason in itself to buy this performance. I have heard everything she did at the Met since 1965, and I find her one of the greatest singers of the 20th century. You may argue with my view of Levine's "Walkure," but I'm sure you don't want to dispute Ms. Ludwig's contribution to music over the past 35 years!

Most people seem to dismiss this "Walkure" because Hildegard Behrens isn't Kirsten Flagstad, Gary Lakes isn't Lauritz Melchior, and James Levine isn't Hans Knappertsbusch. Maybe so. (Although remember the wise old adage: "The Golden Age of opera is always the one you just missed.") But Wagner, more than any other composer, is about the total experience - not just golden throats. And if the participants here aren't clear firsts in every category, their consistent and cumulative excellence make this an extremely competitive candidate.

Let's start with Behrens as everyone's favorite Valkyrie. It's true that she lacks power in the mid-range. But the crucial high notes are strong and shiny. And though they are not as magnificent as Birgit Nilsson's, the outstanding digital sound in which they are captured is a nice consolation. (Opera, like politics, is an art of compromises.)

And Gary Lakes as Siegmund? I'm sure this heresy will earn me a bushel of "unhelpful" votes from the moldy figs. But I have the legendary 1935 Vienna Melchior/Lehmann/List "Walkure" Act I, and I'll take Mr. Lakes, thank you. His instrument may not be the equal of Melchior's Stradivarius, but it's a sweet fiddle all the same (lotsa helden in his tenor) and he plays it far more affectingly, in my opinion.

I'm also prepared to stack up Jessye Norman's almost dementedly passionate Sieglinde against any other essayer of the role. As the mother of the World's Greatest Hero, she ought not to be sung as a swooning Bavarian wildflower. With La Norman's lashing torrents of vocal power, when the character longs to have her shame avenged, you'll know she means it. And when she climactically calls her brother by his true name, you'll want a cigarette afterwards.

If there is a better performance of Hunding than Kurt Moll's, seething with menace, let it be brought forward. I find James Levine an outstanding Wagner conductor - equally adept with the thunderous "Ride of the Valkyries" and the meltingly tender string playing at the end of Act III. And the recorded sound is demonstration class - if you like that sort of thing.

There will always be Solti die-hards and with Birgit Nilsson in his arsenal you can't blame them. But this will be my "Walkure" of choice from now on.

Let me first say that I'm relatively new to the Opera world; therefore, my opinion may not hold much weight. However, I must say this: I love this recording!! Hildegard's voice is exquisite, Jessye Norman has such a commanding voice in her last passage of the Opera, and James Morris does an AWESOME Wotan. I remember after I had read a lot of negative commentary on this opera, I began to have a negative opinion about Norman's performance; then a friend took me to the side and showed me Norman's last passage in this opera (on the DVD), then every doubt I had about her was destroyed!

My ear is not trained enough for particulars (like diction and such) so I can't comment on that.

Basically, if you're looking for an overall good recording taken at a good tempo, this is it. I have heard the infallible Solti recording of this opera and I quickly grew bored with how slow he had taken some passages, but Nilsson has such a beatiful voice on that recording, too. So, it it just depends on what you want out of the Opera, I suppose

Anyways, as a budding opera listener, I highly reccommend this Opera.

This is the BEST recording of Walkure. James Morris is the greatest Wotan! He makes the character dramatic and a real father instead of some heroic man who screams the entire role! I Don't see how people cannot see that Hildegard Behrens is the ONLY Brunnhilde! Her voice is very good. And YES, it is a SEXY voice! No one else has such an erotic voice! The OTHER Brunnhilde Miss Birgit, is o.k. to ME, she sounds as if she is screaming the role, but she is still good if you like the other ring recordings. This is the best recording of such a great opera w/a great cast, fine orchestra and wonderful conducting! This is a must have! Something different.

I saw this performance twice at the Met in 1990. I adore the Ring, beyond any words that I can use to describe it.
I can't remember the first time I heard Die Walkure, but I remember clearly the first time I took a friend of mine to see this performance. She didn't know opera, let alone Wagner. During the 3rd act, during the scene when Wotan says good-bye to his daughter, just before she is put to sleep, (the genius of great art touching someone for the first time), they are in process of embracing one another for the last time, I looked over at her and she was crying, tears were running down her face! And this was before subtitles! She knew the story,we had discussed it,...I will never forget that sight. This performance will touch you, Behrens is not the greatest Brunhilde but Ludwig is probably one of the greatest Frickas, and in the end it all comes together, passionately together.

I am not a fan of the recent Behrens. Her voice, in the DVD of the ring cycle,( different from the CD's by several years!) is far drier than on disc. On disc, she is tolerable, even good most of the time, though as one reviewer so cleverly put it, Norman's Siegliende sounds like she could eat the Valkyries alive. I would give anything to switch the roles having Behrnes as Siegliende and Norman as Brunnhilde. Why couldnt the met think of that-the Valkyrie is a strong noble woman-Norman would be perfect-
The star of the show is James Morris' Wotan. His voice is like liquid gold, pure butter. OF all the Wotan's I have heard, his is the most effective, even moreso on the DVD set. Some may complain about his legato ladden singing, but this adds an immense beauty to the performance which truly makes you yearn for his every word. In the group I watched the whole cycle with, every time he sang, everyone shut up and was in awe of his performance. The only performance I believe is comparable is KNA's 56 Hotter. It is the only perforamcen by Hotter I think is successful, though his Solti Walkure Wotan may be the worst performance of disc. IT sounds like he is singing, or was recorded in a cave. Stray from that horrid performance. Also Karajan's is pretty good, one of the best. Barenboim;s is decent, tomlinson is strong with a great voice, but he tends to overemphasize certain phrases
For a wonderful comparison of what makes Morris great, I compared his lines in
"Der Alt Sturm' to Fricka regarding Siegliende and Siegmunde to
KNA, KRauss, Solti, Barenboim, Morris DVD, and CD and Haitink
Morris is the best.

You will not hear another Walkure in which the characters are so successfully realized. The orchestra is perfection, the singers world class if not immortal. The final scene is my nominee for the most beautiful ever recorded.

Qué gran versión ésta de James Levine! Realmente quedé plenamente satisfecho, prácticamente con todo, excelentes solistas, bien grabada, bajo una concepción extraordinaria del Maestro Levine. Cualquier wagneriano debe escuchar ésta gran versión. Es tal así que después de disfrutar tanto éste Die Walkure de Levine, que voy a adquirir las otras Operas del Ring por el MET. Seguramente podíamos hacer algunas críticas pero la verdad ante tanta maravilla, estas estarían fuera de lugar.

RECOMENDADA CON ENTUSIASMO!