From School Library Journal
Grade 3-4–Gibbons leaps backward into the world of dinosaurs, starting with the cosmic event that may have caused their extinction 65 million years ago. From there she reviews the three geologic periods of the Age of Dinosaurs and provides a brief history of paleontology and its modern methods. What follows are busy pictorial spreads that feature a variety of saurians by classification (e.g., ceratopsians, stegasaurs, etc.) The swirling colorful illustrations depict enough dinos to satisfy novices, though
Oviraptor lacks his crest and definitive beak, and
Kentrosaurus his formidable shoulder spikes. Also, while
Torosaurus once held the slot for the largest skull, it has been ousted by a recent find of an even larger pentoceratopsian skull. No dimensions are provided, but the nesting behavior of
Maiasaurus is shown, as is the evolutionary connection between small theropods and modern birds. The book is vigorous, crowded, and slightly flawed, but it will entice young novices into demanding MORE.–
Patricia Manning, formerly at Eastchester Public Library, NY Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Gr. 1-3. Unlike dinosaurs themselves, fascination with these prehistoric creatures continues to flourish. Gibbons focuses on the most recent theories about dinosaur history, abetted by facts unearthed by new dinosaur discoveries. Following a two-page spread that presents the three periods of the Age of Dinosaurs comes a series of captioned panels with accompanying text that present some basic facts about dinosaurs and their remains. Gibbons then turns attention to seven categories of nonbird dinosaurs, beginning with the earliest, Prosauropods, identifying members of each group in captioned artist's renderings, arranged by period, and noting some individualizing characteristics in an accompanying paragraph of text. More general information follows. Back matter lists nine discoveries, and endpaper maps pinpoint where discoveries have been made. Pronunciation guides appear in parentheses, and there's a handy dinosaur index on the last page. The colorful spreads are a bit crowded, but dinosaurs remain distinct. A high-interest subject, capably simplified.
Julie CumminsCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
