Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
And I thought I didn't care for fantasy...!, May 21, 2002
Bear with me and let me give my bottom-line advice right now : The trilogy of The Secret Texts is a must read for anybody looking for great adventure, exotic settings and endearing characters. And if, like myself, you're curious about the genre but don't care about elves, goblins and traditional wizards, don't worry: Ms. Lisle's Secret Texts will provide you fantasy, but with an edge. Forget the elves and meet the Scarred; trade bearded wizards for dangerously powerful Dragons and cunning Wolves; and expect no damsel in distress : the heroine, Kait Galweigh, can be a tough - and deadly - cookie.What has impressed me first in these three books is the setting. I finished this serie with the impression that Matrin was real and that, given the chance, I could find my way in it: this is what I call impressive worldbuilding. Matrin also includes very distinct territories inhabited by all kinds of different (you could say esthetically challenged but very functional) people. Those features alone would make it worth the trip, but what makes Matrin all the more interesting is that there is a frightful explanation for these variations. No, you can't blame it on the weather... The characterization of the Falcon's and the Dragon's distinct magics is also admirably rigorous: You can't have nothing if you don't give anything first, and Ms. Lisle has given the Falcons and the Dragons drastically different ways of respecting this principle in the use of their magic. The result is magic you can make sense of; no annoying deus ex machina in Matrin's magical systems, and no offense done to the reader's intelligence. As for the characters, well, I liked Kait and Ry, of course. But Ms. Lisle's Secret Texts are filled with endearing second roles. No, you won't yawn your head off when Kait and Ry aren't in the spotlight. Quite the contrary; every character has a story in store that will grab your interest and your heart. And what I appreciated the most in the Secret Texts was that these characters possess strong and plausible motives, and that these motives bring about numerous moral dilemmas. If you think about petty, conventional and easy choices, well, think again. The characters are caught in juicy, enticing, complicated moral issues, and each decision comes with a price to pay. And in Ms. Lisle's books, when characters suffer, it's always to the reader's benefit...! Finally, all these characters gravitate around a story that contains a whole tank truck of unpredictable twists and turns. But again, I never felt cheated: in Ms. Lisle story as in Matrin's magic, everything makes sense. I have only one complain concerning the trilogy, but you can skip this part, as it does not concern the story in itself. It's a problem of almost every fantasy book on the shelves, namely, these covers where you can see an image of the heroes. First, you're bound to discover inconsistencies between the image and the description done by the author (for example, Kait's hair is supposed to be black, and on the covers of the three books, she's either a red-head or strawberry blonde). But really, the biggest problem with this kind of cover is that you're deprived of your own image of the heroes. And when you really, really like a book, well, that stinks, because you'd so much like to think that the strong and witty heroine looks like, say, yourself...!
|
|
|
16 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great! Her break-out book, November 24, 1998
By A Customer
On the planet Matrin, four centuries of bitter fighting between the houses of Dokteerak and Galweigh appear to be finally over with the pending wedding of an individual from each side. While attending the nuptials, Kait Galweigh overhears a treacherous plan that will eradicate her family. In spite of her efforts to save her kin, the plan works, leaving the Galweighs decimated. Kait manages to escape.Heeding a voice telepathically talking inside her head, Kait travels to a remote area of the planet, seeking the mystical Mirror of Souls, which has awakened after a millennium. On her trek, Kait is followed by an unknown enemy, who plan to add her death to their body count. As Kait struggles to survive, she learns that she has the shape-shifting ability of the detested and feared werewolf. With the help of one of her kind, Kait battles for her life as the beginning of a war of magic threatens to destroy her home planet. DIPLOMACY OF WOLVES is a great opening gamut to Holly Lisle's "Secret texts" trilogy. The story line brilliantly mixes politics, betrayal, and magic into a coherent, fun to read speculative fiction novel. Matrin feels like a real planet and the magical aspects come across as if they are a form of physics. However, what makes Ms. Lisle's novel appear to be the tale that takes her to the top of the genre (if justice prevails) is Kait, an enchanting, complex, and genuine person, who will steal the souls of readers. Harriet Klausner 11/8/98
|
|
|
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Intriguing but dark, April 24, 2005
The person who sent this book to me commented that it was "brutal," which made me wonder what, exactly, I was getting myself into. I've read other books by Holly Lisle before and while I wouldn't classify any of them as brutal, I would classify them as dark, and I could easily see how she might cross over that line. It is, after all, but a short step from dark to brutal.
I suppose that, in a way, she was right. There were parts that, taken on their own, I would likely classify as brutal, but I don't think that the book as a whole qualifies. It is, however, definitely a dark fantasy; one in which no excuses are made and evil is given almost as much attention as good. This is not a typical fantasy book.
I think, though, that is a lot of its appeal. It was almost refreshing to read a book that was unapologetically dark, one that did not necessarily offer hope of a brighter tomorrow. It certainly isn't the type of book I would want to read all the time, but it did make a nice change of pace from my normal reading habits.
In <u>Diplomacy of Wolves</u>, Lisle weaves a world full of forbidden magic and intrigue, yet one with so much detail and thought that it seems real. Lisle is a talented world-builder, creating a believable place with many cultures and a solid history. Into it, she puts well-developed characters involved in complex, detailed plot that draws the reader in.
All in all, I would say that <u>Diplomacy of Wolves</u> is a very strong, well-written book.
The one thing that I had a problem with was part of the characterization of Kait, one of the main characters. For the most part, she is well-developed, with both flaws and strengths, and is actually a rather likeable character. However, in her interactions with one other character, she fails to notice obvious slip-ups that someone with her background wouldn't miss. These were the kind of slip-ups that were designed to let the reader know something that the characters weren't supposed to know yet, but they were so glaringly obvious that I found it annoying. Not only was the information conveyed in a poor manner, but it also diminished the characterization of the main character in the book. I can easily think of a few other ways to convey the needed information to the readers that wouldn't have gone against established character traits.
Other than the few slip-ups dealing with that particular information, the rest of the characterization was strong and well-done. In the layers of intrigue, the characters were not always aware of the truth about each other, but Lisle still managed to convey motivation to the readers, even when the characters themselves weren't fully aware of it.
I found the plot to be similarly strong, with several different layers intertwining, yet easy enough to follow and, with the exception of the before-mentioned incident, surprisingly lacking in holes. Given the complexity of the plot, I would have expected more things to slip by Lisle and I was pleasantly surprised to find that there was nothing else that really bothered me or felt as though it was missing.
The world Lisle created in <u>Diplomacy of Wolves</u> may be dark, but it's intriguing, and I for one cannot wait to read more.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Holly Lisle
by Holly Lisle
by Holly Lisle
by Holly Lisle
by Maria V. Snyder
See all Editorial Reviews
