11 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
`Each flash of the camera was a silent shriek', September 27, 2008
This novel kept me turning the pages so rapidly that I didn't actually stop to analyse the story. Which is probably a good thing: I'm not convinced that the various elements hang together well enough to provide a totally satisfying whole. Does it matter? Well, not to me. I was looking for an escapist novel and this book delivered.
There is a lot of action in this novel: not always coherent and not always believable. That will matter to some readers, and ordinarily it matters to me. But sometimes, it is good to suspend reality and just hop onto the rollercoaster.
Jo Beckett is a forensic psychiatrist who profiles victim's lives in order to try to help solve their deaths. Lieutenant Amy Tang calls Jo Beckett to the crime scene after a high speed pursuit in San Francisco ends with four people dead and five injured. So, why did Callie Harding drive her car through a bridge railing? What is the Dirty Secrets Club, and what can Jo do to try to prevent what appear to be a related series of murder/suicides by high profile people? Jo herself looks to be an interesting character as do many of the other `good guys' in this novel.
This was the first Meg Gardiner novel I've read, and it probably won't be the last. I'm intrigued without (yet) being totally hooked.
Jennifer Cameron-Smith
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Skip this One, August 12, 2008
Like a lot of readers, I decided to read Meg Gardiner's work at the recommendation of Stephen King, who has described her as "just as good as Michael Connelly" and the next "superstar of suspense." I've now read two of Gardiner's books, and I now wonder if King and I are reading the same author.
Gardiner is certainly a talented wordsmith, but her plots are so outlandish that I find myself rolling my eyes in disbelief. At least in CHINA LAKE, her debut novel, she had a likable main character and a good sense of pacing. But in THE DIRTY SECRETS CLUB, her most recent standalone novel, she offers neither.
The title of THE DIRTY SECRETS CLUB pretty much explains the plot: it involves a group of rich and powerful individuals who decide to share their dirty laundry with one another. Why they are stupid enough to do this is not convincingly explained. Unsuprisingly, someone begins blackmailing members of the group, many of whom start dying shortly thereafter. It is up to forensic psychiatrist Jo Beckett, Garidner's heroine, to get to the bottom of all this mayhem.
There is very little about THE DIRTY SECRETS CLUB that I liked. The plot is languidly paced, and there are very few suspenseful scenes. Beckett is a bland, cookie-cutter type of heroine that I felt little affection for. The supporting characters mainly consist of stereotypes, and most of their dialog is flat and trite.
The plot of THE DIRTY SECRETS CLUB also contains a lot of silly events and coincidences. For example, the main villain is in police custody in a certain scene, only to have a major earthquake strike the city at precisely the right moment! The lights in the room then black out entirely, and he's able to conveniently slip out in the darkness. He immediately runs down the nearest stairwell, and just happens to run into another character (walking upstairs by himself, of course) that he has a long-standing vendetta against! And so on. If you have no problem believing such an implausable chain of events, then you may just enjoy this book. For me, it was simply too much bad and sloppy plotting to swallow in one sitting.
If you want to try Meg Gardiner, my advice is to try CHINA LAKE. That novel was a mixed bag, but it was loads better than this misfire.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
4 stars, June 20, 2008
A series of strange deaths requires forensic psychologist Jo Beckett to delve into a world hidden beneath San Francisco's psyche where she will discover the tie that mentally binds these victims together. They were all members of the Dirty Secrets Club, a place where nothing was too shocking, indeed, perhaps some things were not shocking enough, to confess. As her frenetic, yet methodical, quest to end the terror continues, Jo finds herself an unwilling member of the club, and thus, a potential victim. Now, she's fighting not only for the dead and for those who might join them, but to save herself as well.
**** Raw tension undergirds almost every page of this gripping thriller that takes you into a twisted maze of psychological suspense. Thanks to shows like Bones or series like Patricia Cornwall's, we are familiar with forensics, but I did not know about the psychiatric aspect of the science. It is by far more fascinating, making this a series that has greater potential than Kay Scarpetta's to seize the reader's imaginations and keep them up at night with all the lights on full force. ****
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No