9 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Yes, Essential, But Lacking Coverage on a Couple Favorites, January 21, 2005
This review is from: Disney Villains: The Essential Guide (DK Essential Guides) (Hardcover)
"Disney Villains: The Essential Guide" is just that, a well-illustrated, detailed guide to most of your favorite Disney villains. From Captain Hook to Maleficent, they're here, including even some info on Disney-Pixar villains. Each of the featured villains gets a detailed description, blurbs all around them for description and information in three important areas: Meanest Moment, Achille's Heel and Pet Peeve. Each also gets a couple of pages devoted to things such as their lair and their dastardly deeds, and you'll even get detailed looks at locations such as Never Land and Pride Rock. This is a feast of information that parents can enjoy reading and looking over with their kids, or can just read on their own.
The main problem with this guide is that it only gives limited coverage on a couple of pages to certain villains, including two of the very best Disney villains: Jafar from "Aladdin" and Hades from "Hercules." Perhaps someday we'll see a Volume II with more info, but until then, these villainous greats are relegated to small, portion-of-a-page blurbs.
If you're a fan of Disney movies, or just wanna learn more about these dastardly villains, definitely get this! I've seen most of the Disney movies, watched the DVDs and read a lot on the Internet (and another unofficial book about the Disney villains) and I still learned a lot from this.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Must Have for "Bad Guy Obsessed" Kids, August 10, 2008
This review is from: Disney Villains: The Essential Guide (DK Essential Guides) (Hardcover)
My 4 year old son is literally obsessed with Bad Guys, esp the Disney ones, and LOVES this book. The pictures are great, and there are lots of little side stories about each villian. We read it every night!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Rather dull, and certainly not essential..., May 2, 2010
This review is from: Disney Villains: The Essential Guide (DK Essential Guides) (Hardcover)
"Disney Villains: The Essential Guide" by Glenn Dakin is not a very exciting book; it is neither educational (as far as film knowledge goes) nor that much fun. Its biggest flaw is that it has a very limited coverage regarding classic Disney villains; some are described and analyzed through a span of three full pages, others are barely listed, while some are not even mentioned or featured at all.
The information regarding the featured villains is presented with a touch of humor and irony that somehow dies halfway through the book. Some of the claims are rather poor attempts at humor. For instance, Maleficent's description of the three good fairies in
Sleeping Beauty (1959) left me saying "okay, then." and almost had me roll my eyes. The suggestion that
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (1937)'s Queen Grimhilde (who is never referred to as anything but the "Evil Queen" suggesting a lack of research on the author's part) is actually an old hag made beautiful by the abuse of make-up is rather dumb. The book doesn't glorify the villains in any sense, neither in terms of stile or wit. I disagree that all readers (or viewers) of these films would quickly side along the heroes, when in a story like
Peter Pan (1953), I found the villains far more exciting and likeable than its arrogant, smart-mouthed hero. Irony and sometimes half-baked or cheap humor makes up the first half of the book; the second half only makes references to different scenes in the variety of films from which these villains come. Some of the images included in the book come directly from the films themselves, a very low-quality VHS-like print of the films, that is. It would have been nice to see sharper images, considering this book was released well into the digital video era.
What is unforgivable is the fact that the book would include non-villain characters such as
Finding Nemo's Bruce the shark, and completely neglect some of the classic villains, whose evil schemes were far more wicked and memorable. I'm talking about classic characters such as
Dumbo (1941)'s ringmaster, the Queen of Heart from
Alice in Wonderland (1951), the cruel and black-hearted Madame Medusa from
The Rescuers (1977), the hilariously evil Mad Madame Mim from
The Sword in the Stone (1963), or even the frightening Horned King from the notorious
The Black Cauldron (1985). Any of these villains would have no doubt been more fun to read about than the likes of Randall, Scroop or Emperor Zurg... heck, even Maleficent! How much can you say about a wicked fairy who wants nothing but to kill over not being imvited to a celebration, and is finally defeated by sword resembling a tooth pick even after turning into a fearsome dragon? Well, in any case, despite her incompetence, Maleficent is a pretty classy villain.
All in all, this book is no better than one of Disney's direct-to-video sequels. It shamelessly tries to cash into the success of these popular Walt Disney animated films, offering in return little entertainment or educational values. It's a nice book to check out of your public library, but I wouldn't spend more than a dollar on it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No