Review
'Displaced Fictions will upset and enrage many, but Scutter should be praised for having had the courage to go public with her convictions and for the clarity with which they are argued. . . . Several times her analysis sent me back to the text for another reading and another perspective.' --
Ruth Starke, Viewpoints, Winter 1999'Secondary school teachers and parents who want to encourage their children to be lovers of literature may find this analysis of Australian fiction for young adults a little confronting. Or, they may find Heather Scutter's iconoclastic message that "books are not holy objects" a timely one.' --
Fiona Capp, The Age, 24 April 1999'The strength of Displaced Fictions is in its perceptive disentangling of some threads running through the literature . . . [Heather Scutter] has succeeded in dragging youth literature out of its cosiness.' --
Robin Morrow, The Australian, 22 May 1999Displaced Fictions will upset and enrage many, but Scutter should be praised for having had the courage to go public with her convictions and for the clarity with which they are argued. . . . Several times her analysis sent me back to the text for another reading and another perspective. --
Ruth Starke, Viewpoints, Winter 1999Secondary school teachers and parents who want to encourage their children to be lovers of literature may find this analysis of Australian fiction for young adults a little confronting. Or, they may find Heather Scutter's iconoclastic message that "books are not holy objects" a timely one. --
Fiona Capp, The Age, 24 April 1999The strength of Displaced Fictions is in its perceptive disentangling of some threads running through the literature . . . [Heather Scutter] has succeeded in dragging youth literature out of its cosiness. --
Robin Morrow, The Australian, 22 May 1999There are some who insist that reviewers should concentrate on questions of literary quality and not criticise matters of content, particularly where they touch on moral concerns. However, that view, as Heather Scutter showed recently in her admirably stirring book Displaced Fictions, is quite properly open to vigorous debate. --
Stephen Matthews, Australian Book Review, September 1999
About the Author
Heather Scutter lectures on Children's Literature in the English Department at Monash University, and also gives workshops on Australian young adult fiction to practising secondary teachers. In earlier incarnations she was an English teacher in secondary schools and a 'reading mum' at primary schools. She has two teenage children.