Most Helpful Customer Reviews
8 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An all things to all people that almost succeeds, September 30, 2009
This review is from: Dissecting the Hack: The F0rb1dd3n Network (Hardcover)
Let me get this out of the way: If books could be reviewed as "first effort" this would be a five/five. For a really ambitious book out of the gate it does a decent job of hitting tons of domains from multiple angles to inform, excite, and influence the thought processes of the reader.
To be even more honest had I thumbed through this book before buying it I would not have bought it. A lot of alarms can go off when you see pictures of vendor equipment, tables of network services, and a touch of conspiracy theory in places. Not that those things are inherently bad but it's only a 400 page tome so that's a lot of real estate to be worried about misusing. The authors use those pages as well as can be expected and in a way that even the most jaded readers should be able to ~respect~ if not always appreciate.
I'm not being hard on this book, trust me. It's now the third book, along with Silence on the Wire, and Anderson's Security Engineering, I expect all newer ITSec professionals to read early and often. I don't judge a non-textbook by the accuracy or timeliness of every statement. Or the quality of the story telling or case studied. I judge these types of books by their ability to affect ~thought processes~, ~perspective~, and ~risk analysis~... and I think this book is a winner on all three counts. It is all about influencing thought, not hand-feeding PRECISE EXACTING and ultimately useless step-by-step hacks.
Solid 4/4.5 star on any scale and a 5/5 for a new set of authors. I hope the editors and publisher give them the opportunity to add about 120/150 pages and build a community. One last note, the books and resources noted within this book are good stand-up lists and should not be overlooked either. The single paragraph stories from the web or people profiles are not to be skipped over.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent book that delivers exactly what it claims, October 20, 2009
This review is from: Dissecting the Hack: The F0rb1dd3n Network (Hardcover)
Very interesting approach to a security/hacker book. Not your usual "manual" that becomes obsolete after less than a year after being published (check out how many editions there are for "hacking 101" books). This book takes the reader through a sci-fi novel that is not really sci-fi... All the techniques (and they should be regarded as such - techniques rather than a specific tool or application) are real, and the examples in the 2nd part of the book (the reference) are up-to-date and easy on the reader.
I would highly recommend giving this book to anyone who has anything to do with corporate information in order to help them speak the same language without scaring them with geek/tech/whiz terminology. Every "hack" in the book - from the social engineering ones, through the software and physical hacks are real and clearly explained.
What not to expect: this isn't a reference manual for how to break things. This is not a technical manual of any kind. This is not a "how to become a penetration tester" book (and don't buy books that claim to make you one).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Unique format on information security, May 12, 2010
This review is from: Dissecting the Hack: The F0rb1dd3n Network (Hardcover)
Dissecting the Hack describes information security in a unique perspective which was quite intriguing. The book is divided into two parts, the F0rbidd3n and Security Threats Are Real (STAR). The F0rbidd3n part is a fictional story of displaying the offensive and defensive mechanisms of network security through a group of knowledgeable teen hackers and black hat hackers. In addition, describing the culture and motives of each side. The story goes through a wide variety of realistic corporate and personal network security attacks and each attack has a reference to the second part of the book. The second part, STAR, is divided into its own chapters going through the author's methodology for penetration testing. Each chapter references a part in the F0rbidd3n fictional story and gives a more detailed analysis on the possibility of the attack. However, it does not give a "how-to" explanation but references books, tools, or news events.
I certainly enjoyed reading the F0rbidd3n part of the book and the format of the two parts. The second part, STAR, was rather basic. I would assume anyone with intermediate knowledge or above of information security would have the same feeling. I would definitely recommend this book to a beginner or someone wanting to get an idea of information security and the effects of being vulnerable.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
