From School Library Journal
PreSchool-K-Walsh is at it again-this time focusing on different activities and just who can (and can't) perform them. The basic format remains the same as in Do Pigs Have Stripes? (1996) and Do Monkeys Tweet? (1997, both Houghton). Seemingly straightforward questions are guaranteed to prompt giggles and denials from young listeners. "Do pigs buzz around flowers?/No, bees buzz around flowers." Illustrations are chunky and charming, and set on brightly colored backgrounds. The simple text is repetitive enough that young listeners will catch on to the pattern right away, but varied enough that it does not become tedious. The author answers every question but the last in the negative-but she manages to sneak some surprises in along the way. "Do hippos hop?" is followed not by the expected rabbit but by a tiny flea, and where some readers might expect to find some ducks ("Do chickens swim underwater?"), Walsh offers fish instead. Add to this the charming subtlety of never answering the title question in words but including a visual clue on the title page, and adults will realize that this deceptively simple silliness is well thought out and perfectly executed. Kids won't care about these details, though; they'll be too busy having fun.
Lisa Dennis, The Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh, PA Copyright 2000 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Kirkus Reviews
Walsh has produced another sure-fire toddler treat in this series of questions that will have an audience of one or a dozen shouting out the answers. Following a format cued by the cover image of a tutu-ed donkey, on the opening page where a small girl is wearing that tutu, Walsh asks, Do pigs buzz around flowers? and on the next spread, No, bees buzz around flowers. A query about hippos hopping is followed by a flea, who does hop, and about ladybugs standing on one leg followed by flamingos who do, and so on. The economically worded questions float on pages of deceptively simple illustration: recognizable but pared-down shapes in clear, matte colors. Sometimes the angles and perspectives are changed, as when we see only the bottom third of a hopping kangaroo. The final twist, Can you fly up in the sky?, is answered affirmatively by a clutch of children in an airplane. A fine addition to Do Pigs Have Stripes? and Do Monkeys Tweet? (not reviewed). (Picture book. 3-6)--
Copyright © 2000 Kirkus Associates, LP. All rights reserved.