Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
23 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
I'm buying another copy for the same kid!, June 21, 2007
I picked this up for my daughter during a trip I took to London two years ago. She was a four year old budding artist and this was her new favorite book. It stretched her imagination and prompted her to produce the most wonderful drawings. And no kidding, this kept her busy for hours. The only trouble was (is) sometimes she had to have the few words on the page read to her to help her figure out what to do on each page.
I have been waiting for this to become available in America because she filled in her other one.
I am the daughter of a therapist who was opposed to the concept of coloring books that kept children drawing inside the lines. This is not like that. Catlow puts a half of a drawing on the page and invites the child to draw what is going on on the rest of the page, to provide the explanation of what is already drawn. It's been fabulous to watch her mind work as she comes up with what's going on on each page. Color is optional, what it's doing is encouraging the kid to expand or create. In fact, my daughter now does not at all like the standard coloring books. She asks me to buy blank notebooks and she draws in the "coloring book" outlines, then fills them in or "colors" them or not as she feels like it. In other words, she has continued with what she learned in this book and would rather make her own Catlow book than color in a standard coloring book.
There is another Doodle book with a gray cover, Doodles by Taro Gomi, which we bought for her when she filled up this yellow one, and it's good but probably for an older kid, I'm guessing 8 years or something. In the Gomi one they're asked to fill in word bubbles to indicate what people are saying... it just seems a little more suited for a slightly older kid who already can read and write.
I'm buying two of these Catlow books, one for my six year old daughter who filled in the first book, and one for my four year old. Oh wait, a third one for my five year old niece's birthday next month.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Everyone wanted their own copy!, May 5, 2009
This book has appealed to everyone in our family (ranging in age from 5 to 48) so much that everyone ultimately got their own copy. There are so many ways to enjoy this book - we've done everything from doing the same pages separately and then comparing, to working side by side on a two-page doodle and discussing what should go into the picture next. Neither of our kids has ever liked coloring books or coloring in general, yet both took immediately to this book. They will often swap books and ask each other questions about their drawings and I'm often struck by the level of thought they've put into their drawings. Definitely worth every penny!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Super duper story starters, October 29, 2009
My son (age 7) has liked these books for a couple years now. This year we got him the Do You Doodle? as part of his schooling. He does the pictures as usual, which I feel encourage creativity and fun. They are much more interesting for the older child than simple coloring books. In a regular coloring book, you are stuck with the picture that is there, but here you are encouraged to use your own imagination and personality to complete the picture to your liking. And then color it or enhance it as you like. Some are just silly pictures (add measles to a line drawing of a boy), but some encourage some more thought and creativity, such as drawing a machine or a way out of a hole for a kid shown in an underground hole or box. My son has a beautifully creative mind, and these books suit him perfectly. This year, we are using them as writing prompts for creative writing. Most writing prompts leave him totally cold. This year he is picking one of his own drawings (a page in this book) as the prompt for a journal entry about once a week. He has gone from really dull uninterested writing to at least some though and excitement when writing about a specific complicated machine picture he made, or even about the boy with measles covering his body in the drawing. These also make excellent "car trip" books.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|