Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Enjoyable, quick read!, January 7, 2005
I really enjoyed the start to this new series. I am an adult and I did not feel like I was reading a children's book. In fact I learned a lot of information, like what a ha-ha is (it's not a laugh by the way :) Pip, Tim and Sebastian are bright kids (even though technically Sebastian is not a kid). My only complaint is that is was too short for me. While for a children's book it might be a good length, as an adult reading it, I have come to expect longer because of the Harry Potter series and books like Eragon. I highly recommend this book for people of all ages, especially if you like fantasy and magic!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
An interesting, but flawed book, November 4, 2004
I think I must agree with the last reviewer that I would like to have been able to give this book 2.5 stars, halfway between good and bad. So I guess I'll have to settle for giving it two and then letting it all even out in the tally. The book is well-written and the premise intriguing, which is why I picked it up in the first place. I was very interested in the information about Alchemy (which the author claims is authentic, thus highlighting the interest factor) and the title character, who was mysterious enough to draw me in but not so mysterious as to make me angry about held back information. The other two main characters, Pip and Tim, are also interesting, but not very stand-out. They show up, they do what they are supposed to, they will continue on to the next book. What I found most annoying about this book is all of the pop culture references. I know this story is for a teen audience, but did the author have to try so hard to prove that he is up with the lingo, hip, and knowledgeable about what kids do in their spare time? Do we need to know that Tim is obsessed with MTV and the cartoon network? Absolutely necessary that they have Pepsi in the house instead of just cola or soda? And et cetera. I felt like maybe there was product placement money coming in. Though this book is supposed to be for the 8 - 12 year old crowd, I wondered at some points if it was really appropriate for that age. Then agin, these kids may be reading worse in terms of scariness or gore in those Goosebumps books. But I must warn you (SPOILER!) that there are severed limbs, suggestions and discussions of brutal murders of people and animals, and an appearance by the Devil. So there ya go. When this books says it deals with the dark side of Alchemy, it is not kidding. Overall, I felt very meh about this book. It didn't wow me, but it wasn't horrible. A few things here and there didn't do it for me, but the book isn't horrible. I will be interested in seeing what happens in the next two.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Semi-qualified "Doctor", December 22, 2004
Martin Booth tries for a more sophisticated magical journey than Harry Potter, in "Doctor Illuminatus: The Alchemist's Son Part I." Taking a pretty typical fantasy good vs. evil story, Booth weaves in history and alchemy, but his handling of the plot is rather clumsy. Pip and her know-it-all twin Tim have just moved into a rambling English country estate, far from the pop-culture world they formerly had. Then scrabbling noises inside the wall are revealed to be something else entirely -- a boy called Sebastian emerges, claiming to be the son of the man who built the house. He's also the son of an alchemist, and he's hibernated for centuries. Sebastian reveals that he is not the only alchemist who has hibernated to the modern day -- an evil enemy named de Loudeac has also survived to the present day. Now de Loudeac is stalking the kids, and is building a homunculus -- a soulless automaton that will do whatever he wants. It's up to Pip, Tim and Sebastian to stop him. If anyone thought that the latest Harry Potter novels were oh-so-dark, then they will be scared witless by this dark fantasy. Booth takes a step into nastier territory, with severed limbs, undead hippies, and a cameo by Satan. And he takes some history (medieval and alchemical) to base the entire plot on. But Booth does have a slightly clumsy way of writing fantasy. Sebastian launches into long lectures every chapter or so, and Booth doesn't manage to make them interesting. And the homunculus is built up as a big threat, then gets toasted within a page of appearing. However, he has a pretty solid writing style, with plenty of details and creepiness. Pip and Tim are fairly good heroes -- a little passive for my taste, but their gradual adjustment to a world of alchemists and magic is well done. Pip in particular is a good lead character, with plenty of promise. Sebastian is not so likable. He's a rather annoying know-it-all, and he never once acts like a twelve-year-old. Martin Booth's "Doctor Illuminatus: The Alchemist's Son Part I" has some deep flaws, but it also has quite a bit of promise for Booth's future alchemy books. Worth checking out, for patient readers of dark books.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|