Most Helpful Customer Reviews
16 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Funny, Tough Story With Bite And Heart--Just Like Its Title, September 3, 2010
This review is from: Dogfight, A Love Story (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
Matt Burgess, in the perfectly titled "Dogfight, A Love Story," has crafted a delicately balanced novel with both bite and heart. Set in the post 9/11 era borough of Queens, "Dogfight" introduces us to a low-level criminal type named Alfredo Batista. Alfredo has a big day ahead--his brother Tariq is getting out of prison! Whether that is good or not remains to be seen. You see, some think that Alfredo turned his brother in. While that may be up for debate, the one thing that is undeniable is that Alfredo is now living with Tariq's ex-girlfriend and is fathering a child with her. What's a good brother to do for this homecoming event? Why, of course, he needs to steal some drugs as a present and set up a dogfight for a party! It only makes sense!
But lest you think that "Dogfight" is a brutal story about the mean streets--let me just interject that the novel is genuinely funny as well. Burgess's principle success is his characterization of Alfredo. A hero, a villain, a lover, a fighter--Alfredo is mostly a mixed up kid with good intentions that is surviving anyway he knows how. Unfortunately, the thing he seems to do best is to get over his head. With real dreams and even bigger worries, Alfredo's trying to step up and be a responsible man. It's a dynamic and fully realized character--and I absolutely loved Alfredo as much as I wanted to throttle him.
Interactions between Alfredo and Tariq are suitably complex. Alfredo's relationships are all well formed, in fact. His parents, his best friend, his surrogate father figure, his girl and even his unborn baby all figure prominently in Alfredo's decisions. There is a real underlying sweetness, despite the unpleasantness, that keeps you really rooting for things to work out! But as the day rushes toward an inevitably violent climax at the dogfight, Burgess builds suspense like a pro. Gritty, yet tender--brutal, yet heartfelt--tragic, yet laugh-out-loud funny--"Dogfight, A Love Story" walks a tightrope in its tone and does so perfectly. A definite recommendation because I actually cared to see what happened with these characters!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Just terrific, August 31, 2010
This review is from: Dogfight, A Love Story (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
Brief summary and review, no spoilers.
The year is 2002, and Alfredo Batista is 19 years old. He and his pregnant girlfriend Isabel live with his parents at their small home in Queens. Alfredo is a high school dropout who makes little money dealing drugs along with his best friend Winston. Alfredo's most pressing concern however is the return of his brother Jose (now going by the name Tariq.) Tariq is being paroled from prison for a burglary committed 2 years earlier. And Tariq might not be very happy because Isabel used to be his girlfriend, and word on the street is that Alfredo ratted Tariq out.
The story is told from various character's point of view. We hear from Alfredo who is understandably stressed about his brother's return and is also apprehensive about his own bleak economic future. We hear from Isabel, and learn about her own upbringing and her concern for her unborn child. And we hear from Tariq, newly converted to Islam, who is struggling with his own demons and inner conflicts.
Alfredo, in an effort to win over Tariq plans to give him some Ecstasy when he gets home. He also plans to stage a dogfight with the same purpose. The problem is that when getting the drugs off of a school drug dealer, Alfredo and Winston end up getting the unwanted and unintended attention and ire of the Russian mob. And their plans for the dogfight have a hitch too - they don't have a dog.
There's a cast of colorful characters, including a 300 pound drug dealer with Cushing's Disease named Baka, an old feisty Jewish shop owner named Max, and a Chevy Impala full of not-so-undercover policemen. To name a few.
This is an astonishingly good book. As you read on and on, there is a palpable sense of tension and dread. It's difficult to put this book down, especially towards the end. You get an absolutely fantastic sense of place and time. This author manages to bring these characters to life and I got a real sense of what life was like for those on the gritty streets of Queens in 2002.
There are many things to recommend about this novel. I thought the writing was just fantastic, and the dialogue was just spot on. This author manages to combine a frightening, bleak and violent story with literally laugh out loud moments. Brilliant, really, and I found myself constantly reading aloud passages to my husband because I thought they were so clever and astute. Such a incredible mix of humor and horror pulled off so adroitly.
Highly recommended. This novel is going on my best of of 2010 list for sure. It's that good.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Strong characters and a funny, powerful story, January 31, 2011
This review is from: Dogfight, A Love Story (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
Dogfight, A Love Story was a love story for me in this sense: I loved reading it. The novel is fresh, very funny, occasionally morbid, and always energetic. It is the product of a very talented writer. In its setting and characters it reminded me of Clockers (a book I greatly enjoyed) minus the cops and with added humor, but the writing in Dogfight is of a higher quality. Burgess' writing style is exactly right for a literary crime novel: sharp and zestful and evocative. The dramatic climax (coming just before an ending that is essentially an epilogue) is frenetic, explosive, intense: powerful stuff that made me utter an involuntary "wow."
Dogfight follows Alfredo Batista during the days before and after his brother Tariq (f/k/a Jose Jr.) is released from prison. While Tariq has been serving his sentence, Alfredo, a small time drug dealer in Queens, has taken up with Tariq's girlfriend, who is now pregnant with Alfredo's child. Worried about his brother's tendency toward violence, Alfredo wants to give him a homecoming present. To that end, he engineers a robbery from a Russian street dealer -- a poor decision that will soon lead to unexpected trouble. He also tries to arrange a dogfight, despite never having seen one (dogfights not being the competition of choice in Queens).
Matt Burgess does a masterful job of merging the plot-driven demands of genre fiction with the character-driven sensibility of literary fiction. Some readers won't like Alfredo or some of the other characters because they commit crimes. But even readers who generally want to read about morally pure characters might find Alfredo to be worth their time. He's imperfect (aren't we all?) but he isn't thuggish. Despite doing something during the novel's course for which he will probably never forgive himself, he has a conscience and he experiences some personal growth, if not full redemption, by the novel's end. In any event, all of the central characters in Dogfight have distinctive, fully realized personalities. It is easy to understand their actions even if the reader might disapprove of them. At least to me, they were all interesting, filled with credible emotions, self-doubt, yearnings, regrets -- all the stuff that makes us human.
Finally, lest you be alarmed by the content of single star reviews from reviewers who didn't bother to read the book before complaining about it, be assured that no dogs were harmed in the writing of this novel. This is a work of fiction, after all. Speaking as someone whose best friend is a golden retriever, I can safely predict that most dog lovers will recognize that this novel does not glorify or glamorize dog fighting. Quite the opposite, in fact. Animal lovers should not avoid this excellent book because of its unfortunate title. In this dog lover's opinion, it is a five star novel.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|