Most Helpful Customer Reviews
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Imaginative, intelligent, and inspiring, October 16, 2000
This book contains essays on author Nollman's experiences using music to communicate with various species, particularly cetaceans. He also provides some very sober observations on how technological culture has exploited other species, what we have lost as a result, and how to begin repairing the damage to ourselves and other creatures. Overall the book inspires hope as well as a greater sense of connection to the beings we share the planet with. My edition of this book is subtitled "The Art and Science of Interspecies Communication." I have to say that there is more art than science here, although not because the author hasn't given some thought as to how to carry out his work scientifically. The problem is that his view of how to carry out interspecies communication studies is innovative and not yet generally accepted by the scientific community. There are only a handful of people carrying out such work, which makes for anecdotal rather than statistically valid results. Nollman's approach differs from the old style of teaching language to chimps, parrots, and dolphins in that it is not human-centered. He writes: "....all...the formalized experiments in interspecies communication share one serious flaw. Every one of them starts by asking the question: Can an animal be taught to communicate with a human being? The animal is the subject, held in a captive situation, and then carefully programmed to learn to give and receive information 'the way that humans do it'.....all we have accomplished is to learn that a chimpanzee, or a dolphin, or whatever animal, can act just a little more like a human being than we had prviously believed possible...." Nollman's alternative is based on mutual respect. Go among the animals in their own environments, participate rather than observe, and find a medium of communication that transcends the human sphere. For Nollman, this medium is music. Using rhythm, tone, chord progressions, and sound textures, he establishes contact with various species, and draws them into musical "dialogs." Sometimes he strikes out, and things don't work out as planned (he's very honest). Other times the results are amazing and yes, awe-inspiring. This book will probably most appeal to those who already have a sense of connection to other living things. I imagine that most reductionists would not make it very far into the book. It's too bad, because although Nollman is an artist and a very open-hearted, empathic human being, he is also good at using logic and science to bolster his point of view. Perhaps the entire crux of his argument against the "animals as machines" school of thought is summed up in what he terms the "Bambi Syndrome." This is the mode of thinking used by skeptics who "cannot accept the reality of animal consciousness until an animal possessed of human consciousness appears on the scene."
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
This book is for the bin., March 14, 2006
This review is from: Dolphin Dreamtime: Talking to the Animals (Hardcover)
I picked up this book because I am a scuba diver with a fascination for Dolphins and always keen to learn something new. There was nothing to be learned here and not very much about Dolphins anyway.
This book is full of the author's fantasies. So much so, I was expecting to read his report of what various animals had said to him at any time.
As an example of how badly the book is written, the following is quoted verbatim from p.102:
"I went to Yellowstone National Park to study and film the annual bugling of the elk. Bull elk really do bugle, and it is a sound which if it did not actually occur, could never be invented. The Tarzan-like call is easily one of the most haunting sounds in all of nature. A bull elk begins bugling (not honking, not trumpeting, but bugling), and all the females within earshot come running to him in sexual anticipation."
Just one example of this author's lack of ability with words and lack of understanding of punctuation.
NM
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
0 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Imaginative, intelligent, and inspiring, October 9, 2000
This book comprises a series of meditative essays on author Nollman's experiences using music as a medium of communication between humans and various species, particularly cetaceans. He also provides some very sober observations on how technological culture has exploited other species, what we have lost in so doing, and how to begin repairing the damage to ourselves and other creatures. Overall the book inspires hope as well as a greater sense of connection to the beings we share the planet with. My edition of this book is subtitled "The Art and Science of Interspecies Communication." I have to say that there is more art than science here, although not because the author hasn't given some thought as to how to carry out his work scientifically. The problem is that his view of how to carry out interspecies communication studies is innovative and not yet generally accepted by the scientific community. There are only a handful of people carrying out such work, which makes for anecdotal rather than statistically valid results. Nollman's approach differs from the old style of teaching language to chimps, parrots, and dolphins in that it is not human-centered. He writes: "....all...the formalized experiments in interspecies communication share one serious flaw. Every one of them starts by asking the question: Can an animal be taught to communicate with a human being? The animal is the subject, held in a captive situation, and then carefully programmed to learn to give and receive information 'the way that humans do it'.....all we have accomplished is to learn that a chimpanzee, or a dolphin, or whatever animal, can act just a little more like a human being than we had prviously believed possible...." Nollman's alternative is based on mutual respect. Go among the animals in their own environments, participate rather than observe, and find a medium of communication that transcends the human sphere. For Nollman, this medium is music. Using rhythm, tone, chord progressions, and sound textures, he establishes contact with various species, and draws them into musical "dialogs." Sometimes he strikes out, and things don't work out as planned (he's very honest). Other times the results are amazing and yes, awe-inspiring. This book will probably most appeal to those who already have a sense of connection to other living things. I imagine that most reductionists would not make it very far into the book. It's too bad, because although Nollman is an artist and a very open-hearted, empathic human being, he is also good at using logic and science to bolster his point of view. Perhaps the entire crux of his argument against the "animals as machines" school of thought is summed up in what he terms the "Bambi Syndrome." This is the mode of thinking used by skeptics who "cannot accept the reality of animal consciousness until an animal possessed of human consciousness appears on the scene."
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
