From Publishers Weekly
Starred Review. Shepard's masterful third book opens in 1976 on Manhattan's Upper West Side as 12-year-old Steven Engel comes home to find his mom, Gina, stabbed to death. The story is divided into three parts, each giving us a different angle on the crime: first from Steven's point of view in the immediate aftermath, then from each of the perspectives of two women removed from the crime but not from its far-reaching reverberations. As Steven is shuffled among caretakers—including Phil, Gina's current boyfriend and a prime suspect—Shepard backgrounds the murder investigation, instead choosing to lay bare Steven's shock and grief in tight, precise terms ("He saw her face again. He felt as if he were standing at the edge of something high"), a strategy that continues throughout the novel. The second part takes place a year later, following schoolteacher Lily Chin, engaged to wealthy Nickolai Belov, as she's confronted by a woman who claims to have been Nickolai's lover—before pointing Lily to where Nickolai has hidden Gina's journal. In the third part, Shepard leaps ahead 10 more years to focus on 73-year-old Louise Carpanetti, suffering from terminal cancer and unsure what to do about her dependant, childlike 55-year-old son, Michael; when she reads about a break in the 12-year-old murder case, she must confront old doubts about her erratic son's involvement. Subtle and rewarding, Shepard's narrative unravels the mystery of Gina's murder obliquely, through her characters' layered relationships, leading to a conclusion that's satisfying, haunting and well deserved.
(May) Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Review
“Shepard has found a voice here that is as strong and confident and full of wise observation.” (O magazine )
“[This] cunningly crafted jigsaw puzzle is colored by vibrant prose and capped by a you’ll-never-guess conclusion.” (Entertainment Weekly )
“Shepard’s masterful third book…leads to a conclusion that’s satisfying, haunting and well deserved.” (Publishers Weekly (starred review) )
“A chilly, disquieting mystery in which the answer to the title is always ‘no.’” (Ron Hansen, author of Mariette in Ecstasy and the National Book Award finalist Atticus )
“Riveting and deeply felt and true.” (Dave Eggers, author of A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius )
“This is a book that haunts and tantalizes and possesses us long after the last page is turned.” (Tim O’Brien author of the Pulitzer Prize finalist The Things They Carried and National Book Award winner for Going After Cacciato )
