Customer Reviews

Doona

5 star:		(0)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(3)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I ordered this under the impression that it contained all three Doona books - decision, crisis and treaty (as the above review states). However, it ONLY has the second and third (crisis and treaty). I'm not too upset because I paid only 4 dollars for it used, but still. Keep this in mind if you plan to buy this book.

On the other hand, Anne McCaffrey is fabulous and I love these books. The three stars is only for the publication itself, not the novels!

McCaffrey is a writer I depend on. That is, whenever I pick up a book by her, I expect to be entertained, swept away, enchanted and completely enthralled by the story which unfolds therein. That said, I was a little disappointed in this book. That's not to say that the book isn't any good - I just want you to know how high my expectations were when I opened it.

All in all, it read more like a a young adult novel than the more sophisticated and intriguing Science Fiction McCaffrey usually weaves. I'm not sure how much that was Nye's influence (I haven't really read any of her other works) or just the target audience. That said, the book itself was a fun and intriguing read, just in places the dialogue and narration felt forced and almost explanatory. I have definitely read better written books.

And this isn't just one book, but actually two: "Crisis on Doona" and "Treaty at Doona". The two primary characters are more like ideals personified, which are then thrown into the most perplexing scenarios which have been incredibly manipulated and the odds stacked against them. Then through a bit of luck, the perseverance of their excellent character, and the help of their loyal friends, they overcome and prevail.

That said, these stories definitely seem to be focused more on the Middle School age and early High School age. I recommend them primarily to those audiences, but, hey, if you're an adult, feel free to dive in - the waters aren't too deep!

This is yet another attempt to re-release a set of stories with nothing new. If you have not read the Doona series then this is your chance to get the whole set of Decision, Crisis and Treaty Planet in one set. Otherwise don't bother.