Customer Reviews

Dot in The Universe: A Novel

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

Lucy Ellman is a revelation. She's an American expat who has taken up residence in England and has acquired the saucy edginess of some of the better English satirists (think of a female Waugh or Amis). While maybe not yet in that league stylistically, she is, at least on the basis of this book, equally as funny.

Ellman's central character, Dot Butser starts out relatively pleased with herself, with her middle class English seaside lifestyle and with her sexually charged husband, whom she believes to be a deep sea fisherman. As the story unfolds, Dot's universe unravells. Hilariously. Bit by bit, Dot comes to see the sordid truth behind the comfortable facade that she has created for herself. She embarks on a quest of self-discovery, depression, suicide, rebirth (several rebirths, in fact, as an assortment of creatures that will have Buddhist and Hindus everywhere chuckling knowingly to themsleves). Finally she comes full circle, in a nice, ironic ending.

Readers who are offended by course language should steer clear. Ellman has the vocabulary of your typical longshoreman. She's pretty graphic about bodily functions and sexual proclivities. But she's not Andrew Dicey Clay. There is a point to her vulgarity, as it reflects the environment she so wittily demolishes. Like all good satirists, she's not too high on the present state of society, neither in England, nor even more negatively, in America.

About the tea cosies. It will give you a brief idea of Ellman's style and humor to illustrate Dot's preoccupation with them. It drives Dot's philandering husband, John, up the wall that she is so obsessed with the things:

"Particularly perturbing to him was Dot's TEA-COSY COLLECTION. They reminded him of his grandma's UNDIES, saggy, baggy and stained.... . Dot's tea cosies were ancient, home-made WOOLEN concoctions, knitted by women inexplicably driven to provide the world with decorative structures in which to house teapots. "

Some readers may be put off by the stylistic device of using ALL CAPS for emphasis, however, I found it an integral part of the humor. I didn't always understand what motivated the choices for why particular words were so emphasized, but I wasn't distracted by it.

Ellman has a great satirical eye and comedic voice. I'm certainly looking forward to reading more titles from this lady. If you're a fan of British satire, or just enjoy a fun, brief read now and again, this short, episodic novel will fill the bill. I had to deduct one star for one Ellman device that gets a bit tiresome after a while. She's obsessed with lists. Sometimes the lists are rather clever and funny. At other times they are mind numbing and one wants to have done with them. In the overall scheme, it's a minor annoyance and Ellman fully succeeded in keeping me entertained for 200 pages.

BEK

In this book Ellman has created a very unusual story that kept me wondering what was going to happen next. While her interest in frequently accentuating words in ALL CAPS is odd at first, once you get used to it, it becomes more like when a friend puts her hand on your arm to emphasise her point during conversation.

The story of Dot reflects much of the malaise in society, and matter of factly and amusingly incorporates some taboo stuff such as infidelity, porno flicks, murder, vivisection and incest. Ellman also has a knack of gettting into tangents, or at least the first seem like tangents, but their power is likly very calucalated. I found her cheeky tirade on What if Animals Did This to You? (where she invites the reader to imagine if animals treated us as we treat them) to be especially amusing.

if you want something cooky, a little bit naughty and very unusual, then this book is or you.

I read this because Michiko Kakutani of the New York Times liked it, and she is like Mikey of cereal-fame...she never likes anything! At any rate, I found this book very funny in a dark way. I laughed out loud several times, an once I got used to the precious use of CAPITAL LETTERS, I liked it very much indeed.

This is one of my favorite novels! The structure and the use of all caps was a little strange but I loved it. The all caps is used to wonderful comic effect and each chapter held new surprises. I could not stop laughing...this is one book I turn to whenever I'm taking life too seriously! It makes you feel like you've stepped into a demented but fantastic alternate universe!

Simply put, it's hot. There is no debating that this is the form of forms. If you don't like it, obviously you fail at life was much as the lead singer of Dead or Alive in their music video You Spin Me Right Round:[....] Especially at 2:20.

Just icky. The humor, while dark, isn't even that funny. Yes, I agree with others, the ALL CAPS is annoying though you do get used to it. I give her credit for writing and getting this drivel published--more than most people have ever done. But the lists that meandered; the murdering of the old annoying ladies, while funny, was just mean; all the sex, oy; hell was interesting for a nanosecond, but move on already, we got it; and the suicides and rebirths--did she deserve it? I lost interest at that point and skipped to the end. I would have given one star but like I said earlier, at least she wrote it and got it published and all of us have read it. So two stars for Lucy and good luck in the future...maybe more structure and less caps next time?

This book is only mildly amusing, and while the circularity of the plot resolves itself quite nicely, it seems the fragmentary nature of the book is structured to encompass the author's personal diatribes against animal testing (severe) and fat americans (actually amusing, and interesting given recent news). The home decorator in Hell is also amusing, and could perhaps be read as social or political commentary. While there are snippets of good writing, the justification for the main suicide is present but vague. And why the words in All CAPS?

This book is just a mess! The author needs to develop better writing skills. One of many things that annoyed me about this book is the author's bizarre habbit of putting words in caps lock. Throughout each page certain words are in caps lock which is not only annoying, it is distracting. It would seem that at some points in this book the author gives up on trying to further the plot by making long lists, sometimes half a page to a page long. So as a tribute to the author I will make my own list of words I would use to describe this book: boring, pointless, waste of paper, money, time, and pathetically bad.

Bought this because the author sounded like a humorist. While she displays some humor, the tale told also is dark, depraved, and disgusting. Started reading this on a dreary day to cheer self up -- very poor choice. Bilge. Stay away from this yuck. Would give it minus-5-stars, if possible. Make that minus-10. If you want a cheerful, fun read, buy Bridget Jones or other books akin to it. Again -- yuck to Dot in the Universe!!!