2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not a great anthology, but better than its companion, January 26, 2002
Although both are long out of print, I enjoyed Card's second anthology more than his first, the companion piece DRAGONS OF LIGHT. Maybe it's because I had more fun reading about scary, man-eating dragons than cute, lovable ones. Maybe it's because the stories in this volume are more dramatic and less comical. Or maybe it's just because a few of these stories tickled my imagination, while none of the others did.
It is still not a great anthology, but three of the fifteen stories are well worth reading.
1. "Alas, My Love, You Do Me Wrong" is a haunting study of a father and son who are unable to relate to each other, and who pay a terrible price.
2. "Negwenya" is a well-crafted piece on racial tensions during apartheid in South Africa.
3. "Plague of Butterflies" is Orson Scott Card's only foray into Latino-style magical realism, with surprisingly good results. (There is a small essay on how this story came to be written in the book "Maps in a Mirror: The Short Fiction of Orson Scott Card").
Unfortunately, there are also more than a few lighthearted duds like "Middle Woman" (written by Card under a pseudonym), "Lady of the Purple Forest", and "Fear of Fly" (in which a lady knight saves a handsome prince-in-distress from a large dragonfly). Plus, a few adventure sci-fi stories like "Storm King" and "Though All the Mountains Lie Between". I was surprised to see "Thermals of August" included since it features an erotic lesbian scene, and Card is known for his religious stance against homosexuality.
Overall, I would not recommend this. Card has published much better science fiction anthologies, such as MASTERPIECES and FUTURE ON ICE.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No