5 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
'Regrettably' and 'Skillfully' do not equate., October 24, 2008
This review is from: Dramatists and Dramas: A Collection of Critical Essays (Bloom's 20th Anniversary Collection) (Paperback)
Having been a reader of Bloom for some time, his new collections I've been purchasing.
As an example, Novelists and Novels had some arguable omissions (where's Dorian Grey?, I thought for a moment.), but I'm not looking for absolute comprehensiveness, and was so much satisfied with the sheer nearness of comprehension he'd managed that any true complaint would be silliness.
Naturally, I'm reading these for Harold Bloom's opinions. They interest me, and they are diverse enough to make exhausting them an amiably impossible task. With this, he did pretty much the one thing that could bugger me into silliness and complaint: he left a great deal of those out.
Well, not even that, he left the Wrong Ones out. You include O'Neill and forget Racine? You say nothing of Calderon and write speculations on the paucity of theater after Shakepseare in Arthur Miller's comically long section? Strindberg - which I was searching for his opinion on - is gone, apparently replaced with a myriad of rather boring 20th Century playwrights.
He owns up to these, and others, in his introduction. The book covers the requisite Athenians, and then devotes a solid third of the book to Shakespeare, which would be fantastic, if I hadn't read his titanic tome of everything he says here and then some:
Shakespeare: The Invention of the Human
Okay, I loved to hear him on Moliere. Thank you Tom Stoppard. Oh, and gracious me, it's about time I encountered someone who could say that about Brecht. Pirandello is here.
I grant him that all this series amounts to is a collection of things written prior, but all the same: Apologizing for your major absences does not fulfill the absence.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No