Customer Reviews

Dream a Dream - Charlotte Church in the Holy Land [VHS]

5 star:		(11)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(3)

 

 

"Charlotte Church in the Holy Land" is so beautiful that it almost defies description. Every track on this DVD, from the very child like "When a Child is Born" to the almost overwhelming power she brings to "O Holy Night" is a world class performance. The setting of this concert - the Dormiton abbey- the resting place of the virgin Mary- is breathtaking, and seems to lend a quality to Charlotte's voice which is unmatched, even on her Christmas CD release.

Charlotte is beautiful, and preternaturally gifted. But this performance is more than just that. She imparts a devotional quality to this material that is obviously unforced. Yet, this is only fitting - she has already brought comfort and joy to millions of people.

I have always wanted to visit the Holy Lands. However, if I do, this Video is a reminder not to take Miss Church along. She provides no more than sterile renditions of religious favorites, while going from place to place with her as the focal point of attention. I would have been much more pleased with her providing a narration of a video of these lands; while being out of sight and refraining from singing. Her voice simply doesn't provide the warmth and emotion necessary to move an individual through such an experience. This video may suffice for an elementary school crowd, but doesn't do it for me.

This is a wonderful production especially for those who always wished they could go to the Holy Land. The Christmas hymns really captivates the essence of Christmas and to be able to see Charlotte Church kneel down to kiss the spot where Jesus was born is itself truly touching. A beautiful and humble girl with God given talents that can move the heart.

Another wonderful presentation by Ms. Church. The quality of the sound and imagery is stunning. Her presentation is better than the previous performance. Her ability to effortlessly sing the high notes like "an angel" is very remarkable. Highly recommended for anyone who appreciates fine music.

Charlotte is not as hot as the public thinks that she is. Her voice is being pushed to much. Look at her jaw...IT QUIVERS!!!! That is the sign of a pushed voice! If a voice is pushed enough, it can bo lost. Charlotte, get a new voice teacher, before it's to late!!!!

If it's at all possible, this supremly talanted child is only getting better each time we see and hear her. If anyone can walk away from this performance dissapointed they either have no taste in music at all or they need an improved audio system in their living room.

I have read, with interest, the opinions of the other reviewers, and I agree that the product promotion at the beginning of this otherwise wonderful and upliftng product is annoying and in very bad taste. Nevertheless, At a time when general appreciation for the meaning of Chistmas is is sorrowfully short supply, I welcome the opportunity to give this DVD to my friends and family, in hopes that Charlotte's gift will give us all a better appreciation for, and motivation to emmulate, the life and example of Jesus Christ. It is an excellent addition to any DVD collection.

First of all, to those who say that Charlotte's mouth quivers, her mouth hardly ever quivered in this concert. She didn't lip sync either. She also did very well with enunciating, which made her singing sound very great. A good listener can also easily tell that the performance is live and genuine because at one point I heard her voice echo in the church hall. You can also tell both she and the orchestra and choir are putting lots of effort into their music.

Besides, this concert DVD was a great pleasure to watch when I recieved it for Christmas. Charlotte sings ten songs from her Christmas album and two from her first album. It's a good chance for American fans who don't have the import to hear "The First Noel", which for some strange reason did not appear on the North American album. The setting of the concert is very beautiful, performed in a lovely Abbey and good camera direction presant fantastic shots of both Charlotte and the orchestra. In between songs, Charlotte takes a tour of the Holy Land, where she visits sites like the ancient church built over the birthplace of the Savior. The DVD has good special features such as a photo gallery and a very early performance of "Silent Night". The whole performance and presantation worked out very well. In fact, I like this concert even more than the Voice of An Angel concert(this concert has better camera angles and lighting). Whether you're a Charlotte fan and/or a faithful Christian, you'll like this very much because Charlotte fans get to see Charlotte perform and Christians get to learn about the holy places Charlotte visits while hearing performances of carols and sacred arias. I am very amazed by the spiritual touch of this concert DVD. Christmas may be over now, but it's probably not too late to check out this DVD.

I have been folowing Ms.Church's career since it began in 1997. I have viewed all her items on the market, but in my opinon, this is Ms.Church at her best.The emotion she puts in the songs, the setting, her mature voice, the info on the Christmas Story-this is the perfect atmosphere for the girl with the "Voice of an Angel"!

I have been following Miss. Church's carreer in awe ever since it began with her talent show appearence when she was twelve. She was a pretty good singer then--not the best--but--pretty good! Now, with every new CD and DVD Miss. Church's wobble, voice control and breath support have really gone downhill. I noticed the wobble on the "Voice of an Angel" DVD but let it slide--knowing she had just turned thirteen, so I said to myself "Okay, so she's got a wobble but I am sure she will fix it" and gosh, was I wrong! On each new DVD she brings out her technique and tone all get a little worse. However, if you are not disturbed by a voice being pushed and do not care about technique and are a fan of Charlotte Church then you should buy this. If you can't stand hearing a young, pushed voice then I would not say that you get this DVD and thats just the bitter truth.