Most Helpful Customer Reviews
25 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Spirit of Romanticism..., September 24, 1999
By A Customer
This review is from: Dream Of The Unified Field (Paperback)
Perhaps the most common indictment made about any of Graham's works is that they are too philosophical and complex--so complex that they distance themselves from the common reader ("reader," these days, meaning someone who expects to understand a poem on the first or second reading). But it would be a great blunder to dismiss her poetry simply because of its complex nature. To me, Graham is a Romantic, in every sense of the word: she writes about everyday experiences (as Wordsworth insisted upon), but then allows these experiences to "move" down the page in an unmistakibly fluid-like fashion. By allowing these experiences to transcend their just being "experiences," Graham allows room for more important, more intellectual, themes to be raised. And while doing this, she maintains firm control over the emotional energies of her poems (and over language itself). When reading one of Graham's more complex pieces (such as those from "Materialism" & "The End of Beaty"), one shouldn't be tricked into thinking that two or three readings alone will provide a clear understanding of the text. Graham forces the reader to read the poems aloud, and to make connections between stanzas and lines (even words) that might otherwise seem disoriented or abstract.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A breathtaking collecton from a brave poet, June 19, 2001
This review is from: Dream Of The Unified Field (Paperback)
Jorie Graham is a poet who is not afraid to tackle big ideas and themes. One of the most disconcerting trends in poems I've read in literary magazines these days is this shying away from intellectualism. So many poems are "look what many epiphanies I can unearth just from my small private world." If you have a violent reaction against these kinds of poems, Jorie Graham's poetry is that antidote you have been searching. She is not afraid to tackle big themes, metaphysical and epistemological. She doesn't hide the fact that she has a sharp, fiercely intelligent mind. But it's not just mere verbal pyrotechnics. She lets her knowledge surface through everyday events observed through her keen eyes, filtered through her sensations. In "Reading Plato", for example, her vision of the platonic community becomes summoned magically, and almost improbably through the sight of men in early morning... fishing at the lake, casting bait into the water, and the horse hair that's attached to it. In other poems, she relates a spiritual surge of St. Theresa to a breakdancer dancing on the street, electricity that seems to run through the dancers bones and limbs. These and many others are startling observations which lead not to easy, pat conclusions and denouements, but to further philosophical inquiries. No other poet I've read recently has drawn out so much from such minute, exacting observations. A work of a genius.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
19 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Conundrum, September 4, 1999
By A Customer
The mystery, really, is two mysteries: how someone so abundantly skilled can fall so far; and second, why? The St. Louis reviewer overstates the case a bit, but the Bostonian is as muddled as he/she is a rummy typist. Basically, Ms. Graham is a stunningly fine poet who has given up on the impulse to break the reader's heart and given in, sadly, to the impulse to baffle with erudition and drop savory hints to theorists along the way. Imagine if Keats had made a similar choice. Though, if he had, we wouldn't know his name by now anyway. Do buy this book. Read the poem "Salmon," from Graham's second collection, EROSION. It's lovely and affecting. Read "Kimomo." Indeed, as the St. Louis person says, after that it's downhill, but there's a kind of literary/aesthetic-Leaving-Las-Vegas fascination to it anyway. It may bring out a certain rage in you or merely disgust. Hell, you may even "like" it, though that seems an odd response to such antiseptically brainy and otherwise void constructions. Good luck.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|