From Publishers Weekly
Carpenter's original lullaby (her contribution to 'Til Their Eyes Shine, a recent CD anthology of lullabies by a number of well-known performing artists) makes for pleasant enough bedtime fare, though it's a shame that the musical notation wasn't included?it's clear from the cadence that these verses were meant to be sung, not just read aloud. The words are geared for gently coaxing little ones to sleep: "Who knows where you'll fly away,/ winging past the light of day?/ The man in the moon and the Milky Way/ welcome you to dreamland." Catering to the same pearly taste, Noonan's (Emma & Mommy Talk to God) oil paintings have the retro flavor of tinted photographs of the '30s and '40s. A cherubic blonde girl drifts off to sleep, floating across a pastel night sky with multiracial companions who emerge from blossoming flowers and who snuggle with stuffed animals?it seems almost unnecessary to add that the stars and the moon all wear smiling faces. There's little middle ground here: readers will find this either saccharine or sweet as spun sugar. Ages 3-7.
Copyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
PreSchool-In this well-intentioned but sticky-sweet effort, a child is kissed goodnight by her bearded daddy and then floats off to Dreamland, where "Every sleepy boy and girl,/in every bed around the world,/can hear the stars up in the sky/whispering a lullaby." The young girl meets smiling stars, big stuffed animals, the man in the moon, and a multicultural cast of children curled up in oversized flowers. The vague text and the cliched images are not the stuff of which dreams are made. The artwork is technically good, but unfortunately matches the lullaby's syrupy mood. The main character bears a striking resemblance to the Breck girl of the '50s. This title by a popular singer-songwriter will probably sell well in bookstores, but libraries can pass on it.
Lauralyn Persson, Wilmette Public Library, ILCopyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.