Most Helpful Customer Reviews
42 of 50 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Confusing modesty with stupidity..., December 11, 2009
This review is from: Dressing with Dignity (Paperback)
As a woman, I find this book offensive and I threw it away because I was ashamed of having it on my shelves. Jesus had an important place for women in His ministry and life. I believe this book encourages women to act in ways that go against the ways He would have them act. As a young Catholic woman I find modesty severely lacking in today's society. There are times that I do raise my eyebrows at what I see people wear to church or the latest fashions. But I also find it improper that this author suggests that by putting on dresses, scorning pants, and embracing an apron we please God. Over and over again we are told to look past earthly things and embrace godly things...whether that be money or expensive clothes or jewels. Why does this author think that an apron or dresses would be any different? Why would she encourage woman to look to material items to guide them in their callings and ministries rather than to God? And Joan of Arc dressed like a man wearing pants and armor, you would be more hard-pressed to find a more holy woman. She then proceeds to start offering weak relationship advice about acting "dreamy" and "helpless" and being pretty for your husband. One, what about nuns? Can you imagine a nun acting dreamy and helpless and mooning around when there is work to be done? Marriage is a vocation too, but both members of that vocation are dedicating it to God. This book seems to almost put the woman's commitment to the man above her commitment to God and the author would have you believe that the only way that you can attract or keep a man is by acting like a ninny. I dress modestly and I dress up for Mass. My husband even likes that I dress modestly and has complimented me on it. I wear an apron because I love to cook and I find it practical and I love vintage clothes. I also have an advanced degree, work outside the home, don't wear makeup, and read and debate with my husband often and about half the time he concedes and smiles and says, "you are right. You so smart, you constantly challenge me and that is why I love you." I think the author is wrong to confuse humilty and modesty with needing to act like a nitwit if you happen to be female. I, for one, plan to raise my daughter to respect herself enough to be modest. I also plan to raise her to consider herself a man's equal, different but equal, and to never make the mistake of thinking that she has to change who she is or hide her intelligence to be appealing to anyone. God made her the way He did, I think it would be a sin to try and pretend differently. Modesty should be about respecting YOURSELF enough to not feel you have to give yourself away and feeling like you have something worth improving. This book has harmful ideas in it...and the writing is awful. Save your money and buy In Search of the Virgin Mary...I find that to be a much better book about a woman's role in the Church.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
30 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
It made me think!, October 28, 2005
This review is from: Dressing with Dignity (Paperback)
I read this book a couple of months ago and took on some of the advice of the author. I started wearing dress/skirts more often. Especially to work and when out in public. I took on a new identity so to speak. I felt comfortable that I was getting attention because I looked soft and feminine. People I would see all the time, like at the gas station, grocery store and even friends took notice. Although the employees at the gas station, attendrd on a regular basis, though I was going to alot of funerals until they asked me one day if I got a job or what? I have worked for 20 years in an office setting and they had never noticed me before by the way I was dressed. This book does offer alot of guide lines to proper attire. I didn't feel the desire to never wear pants again but personally, I think we all need to take it to our own personal level, I feel that these changes have made me feel like the woman God intended me to be. The wife and mother that is an inspiration of why women are so precious. Last but not least if we just take notice of what is proper attire in the house of our Lord that would be a start. I have given this book to a few young girls that don't think about what they wear to church and I have seen a change and have even been thanked. Read this book and take from it what you feel you need to make even a small change. See what it does for you. See what it can do for society.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
26 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
For Those Old Enough To Remember, January 20, 2006
This review is from: Dressing with Dignity (Paperback)
If you were raised as a so-called Baby Boomer in the 1950's and 1960's as I was, you will remember rules and regulations in public and private schools about appropriate dressing attire. This was also the case at a job. My point is simply this: from my recollection, people behaved better and I, for one, think it had a great deal to do with taking the time to care about the language communicated to oneself and others by what we choose to wrap our bodies in. Wealthy or poor it doesn't matter. Unlike books that you cannot judge by their cover, most people judge others by theirs. This book, from a Catholic point of view, and is most sympathetic to mothers and fathers who are at wits' end with their youngsters virtual invitation for "trouble." And this author brilliantly provides do-able ways you can assist yourself, and others, to basically hold back the night - that comes with the never-ending attempts to corrupt our youth through incomprehensible surrender to forces that lead them ultimately down the wrong road. Of course, the clothes alone are not the core issue. And there are always exceptions. But it is what the clothes represent for the one wearing them, and others seeing them. Please buy this book, especially if you are a Mom or Dad. You will never regret it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|