Customer Reviews

Dropping Ashes on the Buddha: The Teachings of Zen Master Seung Sahn

5 star:		(22)
4 star:		(6)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This early book of Stephen Mitchell's is still one of his best. Not only that, but in my own opinion (for whatever _that's_ worth) it belongs on a shortlist of genuinely helpful books on Zen -- next to Kapleau's _Three Pillars of Zen_, Reps's _Zen Flesh, Zen Bones_, Suzuki's _Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind_, and a very few others.

Seung Sahn is a hoot, and Mitchell does a wonderful job presenting his teachings (in 99 fairly short sections, mostly taken from Seung Sahn's Dharma talks and personal correspondence). This book will annoy you in all the right places.

For guidance on koans generally, I like Thomas Cleary's _No Barrier_, recently republished as _Unlocking the Zen Koan_.

(And as other readers have noted, you shouldn't buy this book for advice on sitting, because there isn't any in it.)

The first time I read this book I was stunned. I knew, I just knew, that it made sense somehow. But for the life of me, I could not figure out the "leaping logic" of ZMSS. However, I have kept it by my bedside for almost 5 years now, and a couple times a week, I pick it up, open to a story at random and again enjoy the wisdom contained within it. And believe it or not, after many years of this, I find that the stories all fit together.
This book is the perfect companion to "The Compass of Zen". (Also by ZMSS) Instead of theory, it presents various conversations and letters from the 1970's between the Zen master and his students. On more than one occasion I have found myself nodding in agreement with his students as they question and answer. Only to learn a new lesson from the master.
Now that ZMSS is no longer here in the flesh teaching us, this book is even more important, as the Zen master will be beside us always. Teaching, correcting and guiding. A must have for the serious student of Zen.

After reading this book about a year ago, I finally made the decision to really find out what all this zen stuff was all about. Though as someone "philosophically inclined" it took me some time to wrap my self around his "just don't know" and the like. But never for a moment was I anything but totally engrossed by his presentation. And he's funny too! What more could you want?!? A Stand-up Zen master...exactly what I've been waiting for! For a more complete presentation, check out Seung Sahn's "The Compass of Zen".

"Dropping Ashes on The Buddha" by Zen Master Seung Sahn is a truly unique gem in the boundless sea of Zen literature. It was one of the first books I read on Zen and it had a huge impact on me when I read it much like "Zen Flesh, Zen Bones" did. Like "Zen Flesh, Zen Bones" this book is filled to the brim with humor and compassion and wisdom, defying all logic that will truly awaken you. Seung Sahn was the first teacher to bring Korean Zen Buddhism to America and has since founded his own school. The book was compiled and edited by a student named Stephen Mitchell(whose translation of the "Tao Te Ching" I highly recommend.) The book is a collection of lectures, stories, letters, and stories(both modern and old) all by or having to do with Seung Sahn. It was also great to hear some great Zen stories from the Korean tradition and also a little bit about its lineage. Like koans and other Zen stories, this book shows a great account of buddha nature in action that is beyond words and thinking. Seung Sahn helped erase alot of misconceptions I had in my mind about Zen. I highly recommend this book. I am always re-reading certain stories every now and then and still finding them as fresh as the day I first read them.

Look no further! You made it, you have arrived, this is it: you have found this book. Now open it... Are you laughing yet? This book is a most wonderful key. It will hit right at your core, dazzle you, stun you, strip you, enrich you, bust the locks of your mind, and flung open the doors of your heart . Whoever said Zen 'had' to be austere and bitter anyway? Do yourself the favor of a lifetime: meet this simple and loving man, and listen to his teaching. It's about life, it's about death, empty words and the color of snow, a flag moving in the wind, moments of everyday; it's about you. Everything becomes clear; are you laughing yet?

I finally read this book in its entirety recently after a year of randomly reading the charming stories and koans comprising the book. I love the simplicity of Seung Sahn's teachings. The love he has for his student (you) truly shines through when reading. However, there are other books I would recommend to the beginner who knows little of Zen before this one -introductory books, otherwise the "methods" of zen teaching are easy misunderstood.

This the most entertaining book on Buddhism I have every read. I found myself laughing quite a bit and breezed through the entire books with little effort.

This book does not espouse the conventional methods on obtain enlightenment instead takes a uniquely different approach. I highly recommend anyone interested in the subject to read this book, especially if previous attempts were stifled by weighty material.

Whatever the case I'm positive most people can get something from this book especially since it is couched in such an amusing way.

I have owned numerous copies of this book; lent them out never to see them again. With most books, I don't bother to repurchase them, however I find myself wanting to pick this book up every couple of months to read either a random story or spend a couple hours with it from cover to cover.

If you are looking for a dissertation on zen or buddhism, this might be a bit of a ho-hum read (as other reviewers have asserted, over and over again) but if you can gain insight from the interactions of others... then Dropping Ashes on the Buddha has you covered.

This book is pure joy to read.

"Dropping Ashes on the Buddha" is a collection of Zen Buddhist koans - riddles and stories that defy logic and shock the reader into a new state of consciousness. They are bewildering, funny, shocking, even sacreligous. Most koans are very ancient stories that have been pasted down through the ages, but "Dropping Ashes on the Buddha" combines these old tales with present day stories, and beautifully tie old traditions with modern life in America. Anyone who is interested in Buddhism and especially Zen Buddhism MUST read this book.

Although most of this book speaks directly to the heart and avoids all attempts the reader might have to mentally figure it out, there is a strange logic to it all, and if you give yourself freedom to explore the "logic" you can learn much about how we live our lives on the deepest levels. The Circle of Awareness is especially beautiful and dead-accurate. Seung Sahn is unique in that he is very possibly enlightened in the sense that Buddha was.

A well written book on Zen. Along with "Three pillars of Zen", I've made this book a gift to many of my students. I most like the chapter "The Zen Circle". It is a fine way to desribe "the mind" to anyone interested in this subject matter.