I ordered "Scorpion Tales" after seeing an advertisement for it in an academic catalogue. The book has a catchy title and I thought it might help me with my own research on drug issues. I received a complimentary copy and put in on the shelf. It was the middle of the semester and I had little free time and stacks of other books and articles to read.
One weekend, out of curiosity, I decided to browse the book. I was instantly hooked. I read it in two days. The author, David Macdonald, is an experienced sociologist and a fine story teller. General readers and academic specialists will find much of value in the book, especially in terms of drug issues and the history and culture of Afghanistan. Few other non-fiction books have provided such an earthy, fine-grained account of the human drama of drug use and abuse. I also learned much about the conflictive environment and history within which Afghans struggle to cope with poverty and suffering by cultivating, trading or consuming a wide variety of intoxicating substances.
Among the book's many virtues, I thought the "scorpion tales" motif/metaphor was very well-chosen. (I won't give away the punch line of the story, but suffice it to say that Afghanistan drug folklore is itself mind-bending). I also appreciated the way the author discusses many different drugs (not just opium and heroin) without reifying distinctions between legal, illegal, semi-legal, etc. The treatment of new emerging drug trends, involving some remarkable substances, is another contribution. Additionally, the book provides an even-handed discussion of policy dilemmas and problems (including U.S. responsibility for many of Afghanistan's troubles).
Scorpion Tales deserves a wide audience.
Howard Campbell, Ph.D.
El Paso, Texas (USA)