Like the previous reviewer, I live in NYC and face constant challenges to a restful night. I wanted to buy the original version of the Ecotones sound machine last year after reading about it, but I was put off by the $300 price tag, and wanted to read more reviews before I decided to invest. This year I looked it up again and was thrilled to find this much cheaper version, which has also addressed criticism of the original version (on lighting of the display, ability to manipulate the buttons by touch, etc.). Those of us buying the newer model can thank the "early adopters," I think, as well as the responsiveness of Ecotones. The machine is very easy to turn on and off and adjust even with the display lighting switched off.
The first night I used the machine, it effectively masked the sound, but I wasn't used to it and didn't sleep very well. However, with each use I have found it more conducive to restful sleep, as well as extremely effective in masking unwelcome noise. I like all of the "SoundStories" except the "white noise," which just sounds like static. I don't find the "campfire" very restful, either, but that's because living in an old row house makes one rather wary of the sound of flames! I have found that, as the instructions say, a lower "richness" level is more calming for sleeping.
I opted for this model because it came with pillow speakers at the same cost as the model without them. I now see that the model without pillow speakers is being offered at a lower price. In my opinion, the pillow speakers are not very effective, and it makes sense to pay less and do without them. I like to use earphones with mine, which allows the SoundStories to even more completely mask the external ruckus. My little girl loves listening to the machine through its normal speakers.
In short, my recommendations:
1) Stick with the machine for a few tries and get used to it.
2) Enhance its effectiveness by using earphones.
3) Don't be put off by Ecotones' relatively higher price compared with other brands. Based on the consumer reviews I've read of the other types, it's worth paying more for something that's effective and pleasant to use.