Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
88 of 94 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good for what it is, May 10, 2005
In short, this book provides 410 pages of a simple, focused intro to the game that benefits gamers that are more experienced as well.
The book is divided into five main parts: Chapters one through nine focus on a "D&D Crash course". The focus is on starting out in one of their recommended beginner classes - either fighter, rogue, sorcerer or cleric. Included are simple pre-made characters that will get you playing the game within minutes (assuming someone experienced is DMing). This section will most likely will only be useful for the absolute beginner. Anyone playing more than once or twice could probably skip this section - at least I have so far.
The second part is about "Building a D&D Character". There are chapters dedicated to defining your character, class, ability scores, races, feats, skills, armor (, weapons and gear), spells, and advancing your character. This second part will be very useful for beginning players, as character creation is time-consuming as well as difficult. There are several "trees", or paths recommended for each of the (beginner recommended) classes. For example, in the chapter on feats: there are 3 different "ladders" or paths showing feats for the first 10 levels for the sorcerer/wizard, cleric, fighter and rogue classes. The fighter ladders are melee fighter, skill fighter, and ranged fighter. E.g., the skilled fighter's feats include: 1st: Weapon focus (longsword) and Combat Expertise; 2nd: Dodge; 3rd: Mobility; 4th: Spring Attack; 6th: Whirlwind Attack; 8th: Weapon specialization (longsword); 9th: Improved Disarm; and 10th: Improved Trip. The book then goes on to highlight the strengths, weaknesses, and how to use a skill fighter in combat, and what not to do (e.g., attacking the nearest creature - you should use your higher AC to reach a more important target).
Part III is Playing your Best Game. This section includes tips and advice appropriate for those whom have played more than a couple of times. There is more detailed advice on tactics, group work, etc. E.g., Chapter 13 Handling Yourself in a Fight includes advice on fighting high-AC foes (grapple, flank and aid another) and high DR foes (power attack, sneak attack or magic). Even advanced players should gain something from this section.
Part IV focuses on Dungeon Mastering (DMing). I've never DM'd, but I plan to use this to help me get started DMing. The focus is to simplify the tasks involved in DMing: the book divides the DM's job into five groups, depending what the characters are doing: talking, exploring, fighting, setting up (the adventure) and free time. While those who have DM'd before will have more to comment on in this section, I can see what my previous DMs have done well and what they could've done better (if they had read this book).
The fifth part is the Part of Tens, basically top 10 lists. These include the best sorcerer (including wizard) and cleric spells, low- and mid- level monsters, DM and player resources and the best reading (Wizards of the Coast and others). The discussion of the spells was interesting, and should be especially helpful for beginner and intermediate players (or DMs).
For those of you who do not wish to use the beginner classes outlined, the book is limited. Very little is devoted to druids, paladins, barbarians, rangers, etc. Of course, this is an introductory book and they have to stop somewhere. I would have given this book 5 stars, but I thought the included map was close to useless, and was included just because Dummies book have an insert. That said, I recommend every D&D group get a copy of this book, as all players, from beginning to advanced, will be able to get some new ideas, tactics or inspiration for the game.
Edit: I double-checked the page count, and cannot figure out how they claim to have 432 pages in this book. 410 pages, which I wrote, includes the index. There are 412 pages if you include 2 pages worth of ads for other D&D products.
|
|
|
17 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Exactly what i expected!, October 13, 2005
This book is exactly what I expected from the authors - a well written, useful resource. I have over 10 years playing many editions of D+D and wanted to see what some of the experts had to say and to see their opinions on some of the top 10 lists. I have gleaned some useful information for myself, a person who knows quite a bit, but definately not all of it. Having bought over 40 different resource books, I would rank this among my top 10.
Another very, very obvious use for this book is the benefit it gives newcomers to the game. When 3rd edition first came out, my gaming group drudged through the book for many a session before we finally started to understand the new concepts. D&D for Dummies puts the new ideas, combat maneuvers, some spells, and the confusing Attack of Opportunities in true Dummy book plain English. It is becoming a semi-mandatory read for newbies in my gaming group, it is that useful. It gives a great foundation before attacking the more detailed Players Handbook.
My review is slightly biased, but not overmuch. I am a fan of both authors, the Books for Dummies series (of which I own 8), and obviously D&D. I will say, that if the book was a waste of money, like about 10 D&D resource books I own, I would definately give a negative review. I am glad, however, to give this a high review.
|
|
|
19 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
One of the more helpful guides even for us grognards, November 30, 2006
Interesting batch of reviews this item has generated. As several others, I've being playing RPGs for a very long time (26 yrs). When 3.0, and then 3.5 came out, I felt that a rather simple game had become very complicated. I have sat and read both Player's Manuals, both DMGs, and utilize all 3 Monster Manuals. I still felt somewhat lost and unable to thoroughly and correctly run a game according to all of the new rules. This book changed a lot of that. It is enjoyable to read and explains the rules in a way that really helps you to integrate them into your game. I guess even with my experience I must still qualify as a "Dummy" because I found this book very enlightening and helpful. I highly recommend this book for anyone who needs to either learn the game anew or for anyone who still has questions about 3.0 (and 3.5).
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|