| ||||||||||||||||||||
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
24 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not really about the album...,
By S. Sittig "Divawatch" (Washington, D.C.) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Dusty Springfield's Dusty in Memphis (Thirty Three and a Third series) (Paperback)
As much as I can appreciate being original, and trying a fresh approach to writing, Warren Zanes spends about 20% of his time discussing the album and 80% discussing his childhood, his take on the South, Atlantic records, and other miscellaneous things that have very little if anything to do with "Dusty In Memphis" the famous LP the book is supposedly about.I don't mind that Zanes has taken this different approach, and in a sort of roundabout way, he has covered some of the material necessary to understand this classic pop album, but eventually, even the most open-minded of readers will tire of his tangential musings. There are a few interesting insights into his views on what made Dusty Springfield such a special singer, and what made the material, the arrangements and the musicians on the album so special, but definitely not enough. If you want to really learn more about "Dusty In Memphis" the LP and what went on in the studio, skip this. It's a waste of time. Instead, you can learn much more just by reading the chapter on Memphis in Lucy O'Brien's biography DUSTY or even on the various websites on Dusty Springfield.
13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A very divisive little book!,
By Donald Burnside (Salem, MA) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Dusty Springfield's Dusty in Memphis (Thirty Three and a Third series) (Paperback)
This is the first time I have been moved to post a review on Amazon.com - I feel that Mr. Zanes's book needs defending, particularly from Linda Bowden's review below. I have read this book three times now. Perhaps, for a Dusty Springfield fanatic, there is not enough detail in this book about what Dusty was wearing when she sang her vocals in the studio, or which take ended up being used on the album. I can see the appeal of such minutiae - and I've read enough music books like that in my time. This, however, is something entirely different. And something vastly superior. My main problem with Linda Bowden's review is that she compares the book to a "poorly written high school paper". On the contrary, it's one of the most beautifully written books about music I have ever had the pleasure of reading. (And something else: it's also very funny at times.) I hope that Mr. Zanes or his publishers won't mind me doing this, but here is the very first paragraph of the book: "This is not a book about a record. Sorry. I hope no one has been misled. This is something else altogether. As I was writing it, I conceptualized my agenda in this way: as an attempt to understand why a particular long-playing phonograph, "Dusty in Memphis", pulled me into its world and what I did there. Which is to say, this book is about an experience with a record more than it is about a record. It's both a chronicle and an analysis of what happened when a particular person met up with a particular piece of vinyl at a particular time and the unfolding of that relationship." I have a very bright daughter in high school, and I'm still waiting for the day when she is able to write something as clear and expressive as that! As the book unfolds, we learn a lot (as several reviewers have pointed out) about Mr. Zanes and his relationship with this album. To me, this is perfectly acceptable behavior for the author of a book about pop music. Would it not be stranger for someone to write an appreciation of an album (or a work of visual art, or an opera) while remaining utterly detached and objective? Mr. Zanes is clearly deeply enamored of "Dusty in Memphis", and that love shines from every page of this book. To be sure, he digresses, he wanders, he rambles around the subject. But every single word of this book (OK, perhaps not the amusing aside about Nature's Miracle!) resonates around his theme - which is that the American South is a land of make-believe, and that this extraordinary album reflects that like no other. Another point: Linda Bowden writes that "the author knows nothing about the work that went into the production of this great album". If that is the case, how does she explain the large presence of Jerry Wexler in the book? Mr. Zanes tracks down Wexler - the legendary producer and former head of Atlantic Records - in his retirement in Florida, and extracts some fascinating material from him, which is quoted at length here. I do not wish to demean the opinions of some of the reviewers on here. Anybody looking for a strictly, traditionally written biography of a pop star and her greatest album would be advised to avoid this book. But for those of you with open minds and a taste for a more subjective style of writing, I cannot recommend this book highly enough. It is thoughtful, provocative, warm-hearted, and insightful - and, like the album itself, it will take you into another, more entrancing, world for a while.
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Beats a cup of coffee,
By
This review is from: Dusty Springfield's Dusty in Memphis (Thirty Three and a Third series) (Paperback)
What was so special about Memphis that producer Jerry Wexler took the diva of British pop there and created pop magic? Warren Zanes, 1980s teenage rock star in the Del Fuegos turned PhD (cultural studies) in the 1990s, has written a small book to find out, the first in a series on classic albums. Continuum offers its writers a lot more space than Greil Marcus did in Stranded - 32,000 words by my count - and Zanes uses it brilliantly.
His essay isn't academic deconstruction but a mix of personal passion, acute perceptions and old-fashioned journalistic leg work. Being a musician helps his analysis of what makes the album so special, but even more so is his understanding of Southern culture. He writes of the creatures inhabiting the album; when he hears the opening to `Breakfast in Bed' ("You've been crying, your face is a mess. Come in, baby, you can dry your tears on my dress") he pictures Cloris Leachman in The Last Picture Show. To understand these characters means grasping how the South serves as the backdrop to it all. Not just the South that's there, but the South that's in the popular imagination. "Sweating, carnal, obsessed with the past, violent, agrarian despite the times, natural, authentic, certainly unpredictable ... it sometimes seems that [the weed] kudzu is simply the plant form of a mythology that has already covered the region." Zanes' ideas about the spirit of the South, how it connects with literature, with history, with civil rights and with trash culture - and how it shapes its music - are beautifully expressed and convey a deep understanding of the milieu. His book is unpretentious but profound, avoids hype and self-indulgence while going off on always-relevant tangents that take in Flannery O'Connor, Huck Finn, Alan Lomax, The Dukes of Hazzard and To Kill a Mockingbird. He talks to Wexler and co-producer Chips Moman and, best of all, tracks down Stanley Booth, recluse writer and professional Southerner, who wrote the original liner notes (and the sublime True Adventures of the Rolling Stones). He quotes the influence of a boys adventure book from his youth ("In the North, young men dream about the South. The more discriminating among them slide down the darkness and go straight to Memphis") and explains the magic of Memphis, and Springfield's uncanny way of capturing it. "Led by a singer in a mask, the team that made Dusty in Memphis went after beauty and came up with a little truth." Zanes' essay is the best extended think-piece I have read on music since "Mystery Train", or the contributors to "Stranded". The other writers in the first Continuum series (covering the Kinks' Village Green Preservation Society, Love's Forever Changes, the Smiths' Meat is Murder, Neil Young's Harvest and Pink Floyd's Piper at the Gates of Dawn) have a hard act to follow. (By the way, Linda Bowden's misunderstanding of what this book is about is typified by her connecting it to the Coltrane "Love Supreme" book: that is a completely different approach, a different series, and different publisher.)
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|