From School Library Journal
Grade 3 Up-MacDonald is a grande dame of storytelling, and this is a grand collection. These 41 selections from 30 countries all focus on "the problems in our relationship with nature." The stories range in length from a few paragraphs to seven pages. Each one is preceded by a comment about the theme of the piece and, often, remarks addressed to storytellers. A proverb related to the selection follows each entry. Arranged in 13 thematic groupings, the tales, legends, poems, and fables are all credited to a specific culture, country, or author. Five other well-known storytellers have contributed retellings to the collection. As befits stories from many places, the writing/telling style is noticeably different in each one, reflecting the flavor of the tellers and the language and people of those places. Easy connections between the stories and social-studies units could be made. A delightful choice.
Cris Riedel, Ellis B. Hyde Elementary School, Dansville, NY Copyright 2000 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 6 and up, younger for reading aloud. MacDonald, noted storyteller and author of
Peace Tales (1992), brings the same high-minded, down-to-earth sense of humor and methodical scholarship to this companion volume of folktales, proverbs, poetry, and twentieth-century stories on themes related to nature and the generally disastrous consequences of meddling with it. Most of the selections will be new even to veteran story collectors. Highlights include a funny Hmong tale about vegetables coping with a lazy farmer on one side and pushy weeds on the other. A succinct introduction opens each story, an appropriate proverb closes it, and MacDonald uses simple, breath-conscious phrasing that will be great for story tellers. Enhanced by lists of additional stories and a cultural index, this is an invaluable resource for both environmental studies and general consciousness-raising. Endnotes
John Peters
--This text refers to the
Library Binding
edition.