17 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent Document of Contemporary Culture, May 18, 2006
This review is from: Eat the Document: A Novel (Hardcover)
Dana Spiotta's novel is satisfying on so many levels. Like her predecessor Don DeLillo, Spiotta manages to create a story that is entertaining, deep, and bold all at once. Special kudos go to her for managing to pull off parallel narratives as seamlessly as she does. On a somewhat more subjective note, this is the ideal novel for anyone who is obsessed with the intersection of popular and underground culture, which is to say many of us.
Here's how it works: We see the stories of two generations of resistance culture, both the '60s and '70's hippies and the more punkish subculture of the late '90s. Spiotta, from my vantage, depicts both of these periods spot on, tho' Jason, the son of the fugitive Mary, might be a little more articulate than most any fifteen-year-old I've ever met. Regardless, his obsession with the music of his mother's generation rings true for a mid-adolescent intellectual. His paeans to the Beach Boys are especially compelling. Any fanatic will identify instantly with Jason's reverence for his heroes.
It is not only Jason who is too smart for his own good, it is the entire cast of teenagers who hang around Nash Davis's Prairie Fire bookstore, another delightfully-drawn aspect of _Eat the Document_. Miranda, a punker in her late teens who falls for the middle-aged radical Nash, is painted with true emotional depth, perhaps the best portrait of a countercultural woman of the '90s that I've read. She ends up being torn between Nash and the more conventional Josh, someone who is her own age, but who ends up co-opting his more radical impulses to work for "the man." Nash, on the other hand, never gives into the man. Then again, we might question whether he accomplishes anything at all, as tied into creating ludicrous resistance groups out of his bookshop as he is (a few of the humorous examples of the fun that Nash has with acronyms and organizational monikers: SAP [Strategic Aggravation Players and/or Satyagraha by Antinomic Praxis] and the Neo Tea-Dumpers Front).
For all the humor here (which by the way is not overdone--like so many other aspects of this book, the humor works in naturally), there are all sorts of wonderful philosophical issues being explored, placing Spiotta near the forefront of her postmodern peers. This book is all about living on borderlines, especially the borderline between popular culture and counterculture, a place that really takes maneuvering, as anyone who has truly experienced the counterculture knows. For all the desire to make new vistas for culture, one can't help but buy Starbucks here and there or like "Good Vibrations" by the Beach Boys, even though it is the quintessence of pop. To stick with the Beach Boys, they are the perfect figure for this book to explore, as they never completely lost their clean-cut aura, even as Dennis Wilson was hanging around the Manson family. Dana Spiotta mines this seeming anomaly forcefully and shows the humor, wisdom, and pathos that arises from two generations of outcasts trying to negotiate their place apart from (yet invariably in) a world driven by consumerism. From what I say in that last sentence, I hope you don't get the impression that this is a dry intellectual screed, because it is not. Spiotta has created that relatively rare wonder of prose that explores some of the most spiky of social issues while managing to keep the authorial voice warm throughout. This makes hers a document that not only our generation should read to get a sense of itself, but also generations to come. As highly recommended as contemporary prose comes.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
27 of 32 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Please don't let on that you knew me when..., January 31, 2006
This review is from: Eat the Document: A Novel (Hardcover)
Eat the Document is about hippie activists in hiding, yes, but it is also about longing and loss, identity and authenticity, and the inescapability of destiny. With astounding detail, Spiotta is equally rhapsodic on the fads and follies of two generations of countercultural rebels, but spares neither her sharp eye for hypocrisy, futility, and misplaced desires. All of this she accomplishes with searing wit, virtuosic joy in language, and ultimately, real sensitivity for lives lived on the run. A sweeping, stunning book, from a writer who is beyond smart and who is just hitting her stride. Masterful.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Great premise but ultimately a let down., December 22, 2006
I was very excited to read Dana Spiotta's 'EAT THE DOCUMENT' not only because the premise sounded great but also because of all the praise it had generated. Unfortunately this novel did not live up to my expectations at all. The first three fourths of the book was, in my opinion, nothing more than words on a page. It did not set the stage for the heart of the story nor was it very interesting. So many times I considered putting the book down never to pick it up again, however, an unfinished book nags at me therefore I was compelled to complete it. Only the last hundred or so pages, where the focus was more on the main characters Mary Whittaker and Bobby Desoto, made the book at all redeemable. I would have loved a lot less of the pretentious social commentary and more of an in depth look into SAFE the 70's radical group that Mary and Bobby belonged to as well as a better look into Mary's life not only for the first few years after she went underground but in present day as well.
Although this was not the fast paced thriller about two fugitives separated not only by time but irreparable actions that I thought it was, I am glad that I finished the book because if I hadn't I would have missed the best part of the story. However, this book takes a lot of patience. If you are not into the history of the 70's radical movement and how it relates to today, this may not be the book for you.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No