Customer Reviews

Eat a Peach

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Many thanks are due to whoever is responsible for this fan favorite being mixed to multi-channel SACD. It sounds great! Both the multi-channel and stereo mixes represent a significant advance over the way this disc sounded before.
.
I guess we should start by thanking Jeff Glixman who most folks know as the producer/engineer for KANSAS. He certainly has endeared himself to this Allman Brothers fan for his excellent work in mixing "Eat a Peach" to hi-resolution 5.1.
.
I compared the new SACD to the most recent edition of the CD - the remastered one released a few years back. I listened to the SACD and the CD simultaneously with the CD in Pro Logic II mode (Denon CD player), while the SACD was played back in a Pioneer universal DVD player. Switching back and forth with volume levels matched, it was easy to hear the improvement.
.
The new 5.1 mix has Gregg's voice spread out across all 3 front channels, and the soundstage is much wider than before with the 2 drummers clearly separated between left and right. Soundstage depth is amazing considering that not very much is going on in the surround speakers. Low frequency extension is excellent and fans of Berry Oakley's bass playing will revel in the seismic bottom end. Acoustic guitars sounded like they were being played right there in my living room, while cymbals and other high frequency sounds also sounded like they were being played in my room.
.
This new sense of "presence" can be thought of another way. During "Mountain Jam" for example, I felt transported OUT of my living room and right onto the stage with the band. The 3D illusion is so real, it sounded like I was standing between Duane and Dickey's amps, and right in front of and between Jaimoe and Butch's drum kits. The organ and bass sounded like they were coming from everywhere at once, giving me an experiance of immersion in a 3D soundfield.
.
Unlike other multi-channel SACD's which throw instruments around the room in jarring and unnatural ways, this SACD uses the surround channels simply for ambient reinforcement of the traditional soundstage which is still up front. The genius of this approach is that it preserves the naturalness of the performance, and the traditional soundstage with Duane on the left, Dickey on the right, Jaimoe on the left, Butch on the right etc., while still creating a 3 dimensional immersive experience.
.
Audiophiles who review $100,000 sound systems in magazines like Stereophile often talk about being able to hear the "hall" that the concert was played in as well as the music. The subtlety of Jeff Glixman's approach to this 5.1 mix enabled me to hear the hall (the Fillmore) on my little $2000 system. Kudos to Jeff Glixman for working that miracle!
.
The improvement over the regular CD can be boiled down to: a much wider and deeper soundfield that expands to fill the entire room. Greater high frequency and low frequency extension. Any element in the mix that you would care to name sounds bigger, clearer and closer. The twin lead guitars of Duane and Dickey sound natural and clear, not shrill or brittle. Fans of Berry Oakley will appreciate that the bass now sounds like a bulldozer going downhill with the throttle wide open. Hold on!
.
For those without a multi-channel setup who are interested in the hi-resolution stereo layer, it's wonderful too. Both high and low frequencies are more extended than before, and the soundstage is wider and deeper than the old CD. The drums now sound full-size and close, whereas they used to sound small and somewhat distant. The soundstage is open and transparent with instruments clearly placed in 3D space with plenty of air around each instrument. It really does sound like you're THERE.

First, let me qualify this review by saying that Eat a Peach is one of my favorite albums. This review is not about the album itself or the music. What I really like about the SACD treatment of classic albums is the ability to be completely "immersed" in the "field of play". Another plus with the SACD format is the clarity that it often brings to tracks that were hard to discern in the album's earlier editions. I'd say that the SACD of Eat a Peach accomplishes the latter benefit. "Les Brers" is where this SACD mix really shines, in my opinion, bringing out all of the percussion tracks with great clarity. The live tracks on this disc are also worthy of applause. "One Way Out" and "Trouble No More" have a greater presence and the rhythm section is really pushed to the forefront of these songs, giving them added urgency and a feeling that the performance is happening right in front of you. Unfortunately, this disc does not achieve the full musical immersion that I had really hoped for and that's why it gets 3 stars instead of 4 or 5. "Mountain Jam" is where I really thought the SACD mix would shine and provide that immersion, but I find this mix not to be all that different from previous mixes and certainly no better than the other live tracks on this SACD. That aside, I don't regret this purchase. If you own an SACD player and a system that's capable of playing back the 5 separate channels and you are a fan of the Allman Bros., I heartily recommend this disc.

The Allman Brothers Band are one of the most consistent acts in history, but it must be said they were at their best when slide guitar legend Duane Allman played with them. That group put out a myriad of great albums, both in the studio (s/t; Idlewild South) and live (At Fillmore East/the Fillmore Concerts; Live at the Atlanta International Pop Festival). This was the last album before Duane's tragic death, and it's also the best they ever made, both studio and live. After all, this is a bit of both.
The live tunes come from the same Fillmore shows that produced At Fillmore East and the Fillmore Concerts - in fact, you can find the live tunes on the Fillmore Concerts, so you know they're gonna be good. It starts off with the half-hour "Mountain Jam", which starts off as the melody of Donovan's "First There Is a Mountain". It ends up that way, too, but between the two bookends is when things really get good. They take the song into every imaginable direction - jazzy organ, bass and drum solos, even a quote from "Let the Circle Be Unbroken". But of course the best part, as always, is Duane Allman's slide guitar. It's placed after the bass solo, and it's him at his finest. The other two songs are scaled back considerably, but still very good. Their version of "One Way Out" has got to be one of the best covers ever recorded, due to Duane and Dickey's bar trading during the guitar solos, which are fantastic in their own right. And while I don't like this "Trouble No More" as much as I like the studio version, that's only because it's missing the acoustic rhythm guitar. Point is, it's a fantastic cover either way.
And hey, I haven't even gotten to the studio work yet. That segment features the three big-time hits from this album, one with Duane and two without. The leadoff track, "Ain't Wastin' Time No More", is the first. I always thought this song was inspired by Duane's death, since a lot of it deals with mortality. Regardless of what it is or isn't about, it's a fine song. The highlight is Dickey's slide; Gregg also contributes fine piano and vocals. Good times all around. "Melissa" (or "Sweet Melissa", or whatever) is a forlorn, touching elegy to Duane with just a hit of country, and it's arguably the best song here. On the other hand, "Blue Sky" is a feel-good song with top-notch guitar weaving from Duane and Dickey. It's a breezy country-rocker, sung by Dickey, which began a long (okay, two-album) string of having a big radio hit sung by Betts - the other is, of course, "Ramblin' Man". Dickey also contributes an epic instrumental, "Les Brers in A Minor", which begins with a slow, moody guitar introduction before moving into a boogie with a faint touch of Santana. The third and final instrumental on this album is "Little Martha", a graceful, gorgeous, brief acoustic duet between Duane and Dickey. It's also the only song Duane ever wrote for the group. With all that competition, the funky "Stand Back" can't keep pace, but it's good enough, with a memorable bass solo.
Right here. The Allman Brothers at their best. I've heard it so much I've practically memorized it. It's simply a must-have.

The Allman Brothers Band's "Eat A Peach" was a much anticipated album when it was released in February 1972, coming on the heels of their commercial breakthrough "At Fillmore East" (1971) and the November 1971 death of guitarist Duane Allman. In LP format, which came lavishly packaged and, at least in its first pressings, beautifully mastered, the four sides of this double album made a great deal of structural sense. Side one offered the 'new' ABB, in the form of three new gems recorded shortly after Duane's death. Gregg's originals, though not nececessarily written after his brother's tragic motorcycle accident, nevertheless convey the essence of the blues as deeply as Bobby Bland a decade earlier, and 'Ain't Wasting Time No More' and 'Melissa' both evoke a haunting, mournful tone thanks to some of Greg's most deeply felt vocals; Dicky Betts' nine-minute instrumental "Les Breres" smolders and catches fire much like the classic 'Elizabeth Reed' from "Idlewild South", demonstrating the new lineup retained its telepathy and vitality. Greg's classic songs and Betts' dazzling, extended intsrumental workout were proof positive that for the time at least, the ABB's inventiveness and cohesion remained intact. The second side offered the first 19 minutes of their unhurried, relaxed improvisation, inspired by Donovan's classic 'There Is A Mountain', here titled 'Mountain Jam' and taken from Fillmore shows recorded shortly after the previous year's live album. Side three blazed to yet another peak, with terrific and fascinating new material recorded before Duane's death, fleshed out by two splendid blues workouts also recorded at those Fillmore shows. Of the studio tracks, 'Stand Back' is a soulful rocker reminiscent of Delaney & Bonnie, and 'Blue Sky' is the first (and to these ears best) example of Betts' relaxed, country-inspired lyricism. The side closed with a lovely coda to the first era of the ABB, an acoustic duet between Duane and Dicky called 'Little Martha'. Finally, side four finishes off with the last 15 minutes of 'Mountain Jam'. Every CD edition of "Eat A Peach" eschews the original format, choosing instead to include all 34 minutes of 'Mountain Jam' in one uninterrupted helping. As for this new SACD, it is sonically by far the most impressive version of this album, which capture the Allmans at their peak, sonically. The sound is warm, detailed, and full. You feel the heat and sparks of a breathing entity when all band members shared a focus and goal and were listening and responding to one another. And Gregg's vocals have never sounded so full of soul. Of the three-dozen SACDs I own, only several Rolling Stones titles (issued by ABKCO in 2002, identifiable by the digipaks that house them) and Ronnie Lane/Pete Townshend's deeply moving "Rough Mix" (Hip-o) are nearly as revelatory. Nevertheless I also recommend seeking out a mint copy of the original double album, with the warm tubey sound and fabulous cover art, for though it may be a minority opinion, I find it structurally preferable: 'Mountain Jam' is not the sort of dynamic buildup 'Whipping Post' (from the Fillmore set) is; the pace is far more relaxed, and therefore having it broken up on sides two and four actually makes for a more interesting listening experience. The 34 minute CD version is simply a bit too meandering. Thus I do wish the lp format was used for at least one CD issue. Otherwise EAP is the ABB still at a peak, growing and evolving before the rot began to set in, first evident on the blockbuster 1973 followup "Brothers & Sisters" (a respectable work that nevertheless finds Greg fading into the background and the presence of Betts as the band's dominant songwriter - he was, or had become, simply too bland to carry the weight). B&S was a masterpiece, however, compared to the forced and unconvincing "Win, Lose Or Draw", after which the band broke up until their fine 1979 comeback "Enlightened Rogues". But on their fourth album, "Eat A Peach", Dicky Betts' songwriting voice - a relaxed, countryish contrast to Gregg's blues and soul intensity - is just hitting its stride, and the varied moods and textures, spread over a large canvas, make this one of the major albums of '72.

Superb version of this essential southern rock masterpiece. This SACD version is just plain inspirational. I had a large Brothers collection before updating to SACD recently, and listening to this disc was the first time I was able to hear the crickets on "Little Martha", and I have listened to the Brothers all my life! If you're a rock guitarist, this is a must have disc. "Mountain Jam" is great with Barry Oakley leading the charge with his P-bass, and "One Way Out" is an excellent example of Duane's Blues prowess with a corcidian bottle, an SG, and a 50w Marshall. The mix/mastering of this, (and "At Filmore East"), set a new sonic standard for Allman Brothers fans, and rock in general. If you have an SACD player, you MUST update your catalouge with these two new remasters! End of story.

I have had this disc for quite a while, and was surprised to read some reviews about the SACD treatment lacking in certain aspects.

Quite simply, there is no better way this album will ever sound. In a full range five-speaker system, you are present both in the Fillmore and in the studio. The clarity and balance of the guitars, keyboards, drums, bass and vocals is without comparison to any other version of this album.

This recording conveys a BIG sound and is not digitally sharp or brittle. Duane's slide wallops you with that fat Les Paul tone. The rhythm riffs Duane plays during the Dickey Bett's solos are wondrous on the live material.

The rest of the band plays on extraordinarily, but in my opinion when Duane is in any recording, he steals the show.

This is the best Peach without a doubt.

Since 1972,I have bought this album as vinyl/2 cassettes/2 CDs, and now in a 5.1 surround mix. It is easily the most beautiful mix of a Classic album there is. Also having procured the Dts DVD-A of "Fillmore East," and the SACD of " Layla," I have discovered that Brother Duane has a new home in the world of surround sound. He's always flying high, and he's always in the left rear channel ! Discover for yourself what REAL music from a REAL band CAN sound like !!!

This must have Allman Bros classic recording sound's fantastic on SCCD. I play it back on 2ch SACD and it sounds great. sound is clean and crisp and the presence is close to Vinyl.

I recently discovered my DVD player was capable of playing the SACD format. I first purchased Steely Dan on SACD and was astounded. Unfortunately, Eat A Peach left me feeling like I bought just the pit. Assuming you are buying this for the SACD sound, skip it.