11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The speech-to-speech feature is not useful, February 2, 2007
This review is from: Ectaco TL-2ASIAN5 iTRAVL Multilingual East-Asian 5-Language Translator (Electronics)
I laid out the big bucks for this device because of the speech-to-speech capability that's advertised. But as implemented, this capability is purely a novelty function. You have to pick a particular subcatagory like "Introductions" or "Apologies." A subcatagory has six to eight phrases and you can use the speech-to-speech capability to choose one. (It's simpler to pick one with the stylus.)
Aside from the speech-to-speech stuff, the device just your basic electronic dictionary. The best implimentation is for Japanese, with output in your choice of Kanji, Kana, Roman letters, or voice. The Thai implementation is weak with output only in Thai letters. I compared equivalent lists of word from the English-Chinese section to various other dictionaries and I conclude that that the device has about half as many English words as the Merriam Webster Collegiate Dictionary (50,000 to 60,000 words) and about three times as many English words as my pocket-sized English-Thai paper dictionary, which has nearly 11,000 English words. If every word is translated both ways in every language (a generous assumption), that works out to about 30,000 words for each language, each direction, and 420,000 words across all 14 language dictionaries. (The ad says 5 million words.) As for phrases, there the 15 catagories, each with about 5 subcatagories of about 7 phrases each, so roughly 525 English phrases, or about 7,350 phrases across all 14 language dictionaries (The ad says 70,000.)
Here's a few suggestions to improve the item: Make the keyboard alphabetical. QWERTY is for touch-typing and the keyboard on the screen is much too small for touch-typing. The dictionary should be implemented to allow you to translate more than one word at the same time. If, in addition, the thing had a USB port, I could attach a roll-up keyboard and touch-type in multiple words.
Finally, this is the 800-pound gorilla of electronic dictionaries. It's about the same size as the paper dictionary I have been using (mentioned above). The buttons are huge, so the picture fools you as to the actual size of the item.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No