From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 2–Eddie and his mother ("assisted" by baby sister Lily and applauded by Grandad) plant a veggie garden. Their hard work is recorded in the brief text, and delightfully displayed in the soft watercolors (one appealing illustration shows the siblings sitting inside a "bean den"–long sticks tied together at the top and covered with vines). The family's horticultural efforts (including a late-night slug hunt) are rewarded by a bumper crop, and the ensuing picnic stars peas, carrots, corn, and lettuce (and a pie made from Lily's pumpkin). Novice gardeners will find instructions for growing Eddie's plants, along with other pertinent information on soil, seeds, container gardening, and possible pests, at the back of the book. A wonderful supplement to gems such as Lois Ehlert's
Growing Vegetable Soup (Harcourt, 1987), Rosalind Creasy's
Blue Potatoes, Orange Tomatoes (Sierra Club, 1997), and Michael Rosen's stunning
Down to Earth (Harcourt, 1998), Garland's offering will inspire young children to ask for a bit of earth (or a couple of pots) to try out their green thumbs.
–Patricia Manning, formerly at Eastchester Public Library, NY Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
K-Gr. 3. Watching their mother dig in her garden, Eddie and his little sister, Lily, ask for their own. During the next few months, Eddie plants seeds, waters them, helps Lily, watches their plants grow, hunts slugs, harvests vegetables, and eats the home-grown produce. Bits of humor in the telling and appealing visual elements such as a bean-pole teepee will help keep children involved in the story. This book ends with four helpful pages explaining how to grow "Eddie's plants," such as carrots, nasturtiums, and sunflowers, as well as discussing soil, seeds, pests, hazards, and gardening indoors and in containers. Evidently a labor of love for Garland, an English writer and illustrator who has written an adult book on plants, this picture book offers plenty of genial details in the bright, engaging colored artwork.
Carolyn PhelanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved