Most Helpful Customer Reviews
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
delightful sports historical thriller, May 16, 2007
This review is from: The Edict: A Novel from the Beginnings of Golf (Hardcover)
In the fifteenth century, golf has become the national pastime of Scotland with only raiding matching it with intensity. So popular is the sport, raiding is halted during the annual tournament at St. Andrews while betting on the players is hot.
The favorite to win the St. Andrews tourney in 1457 is shepherd Caeril Patersone. However, a noble panics when he realizes he made a stupid bet. To insure that Caeril fails to win the event, he writes off a debt in exchange for beautiful Eta to distract the favorite. If that fails, he still has his ace in the hole of appealing to King James II to ban the sport and consequently the tournament because he has proof too many soldiers hit the links instead of the archery range.
THE EDICT is a delightful sports historical thriller based on a real event that occurred in Scotland when the King outlawed golf on March 4, 1457. Readers will root for Caeril, who in spite of being the best golfer in the tournament, is a decided underdog because the fix is in. Historical readers and golf aficionados will believe that Bob Cupp is a masterful author as he makes birdies and eagles with this ace of a fifteenth century sports saga.
Harriet Klausner
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Such an interesting read, July 30, 2008
The word `golf' first appeared in a 1457 Scottish Edict banning the Scots from playing in order to turn their focus to archery and defend their realm from the English. And so The Edict is a fanciful tale by Bob Cupp about how such a law could have found its way out of the parliament.
In the community of Fife a structure was built to honor St. Andrew, patron saint of Scotland, brother to Peter and an apostle to Jesus. This would become the ecclesiastic cornerstone to pilgrims and golf tournaments, increasing the community population exponentially. It is in this backdrop that Cupp writes about a famed tournament that caused the King to outlaw golf on March 6, 1457.
The Edict is the story about a shepherd with a natural talent, who could win the event and be the next celebrated hero of the games. However there are two evil ruffians who go out of their way to cause him to fall short of his dream. A nobleman with a major betting problem realizes he has seriously placed himself in jeopardy by making an ill-advised bet, and an evil lender who plays innocent people against each other, creating a community of distrust, who use skullduggery to prevent the dark horse from winning.
In a Foreword written by Jack Nicklaus, he describes Bob Cupp as one of the most talented golf course designers who has the ability to turn red clay into brilliant fairways. In addition to his vivid imagination, Bob has a healthy sense of humor and the gift of gab. Hence, Jack believes The Edict is important to golf in that it brings to life the possibilities of golf's rudiment beginnings.
Whether you are a casual or serious golfer, The Edict will inspire greater passion and a reverence for the game. I don't believe any reader can honestly read this book and not want to pick up a set a clubs. As a casual golfer that is exactly what I did and I felt a new understanding for the nuances of golf. Thanks Bob!
Armchair Interviews says: You don't have to be a golfer to enjoy.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Magnificent Spin or Yarn on Golf's Scottish Origins, June 24, 2008
What a marvelous read Cupp has given us! From his prose (whom he graciously acknowledges he had help with) to his research into Scotland and the line drawings, the total product is to be fully inhaled, exhaled, re-inhaled and given away as presents. This book is soooo good!
The romp through history and shepherds boredom to the course designer and the final edict is truly captivating and delightful reading. Golfers will adore it, and even the non-golfer would likely enjoy this read through time.
Aficionados will find the likes of Hogan, Palmer and Nicklaus in here as well as USGA, etc.
By all means, buy this book and read it. Anybody else wonder if this could be made into movie?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|