"Among many other virtues of this study of Stein as thinker is MacIntyre's magnificent demonstration of how any philosopher must be situated in the context of where she studied, who her mentors were and the historical moment both inside and outside the academy. A bravo performance."
(Kenneth L. Woodward
Newsweek )
'...a comprehensive introduction to Edith Stein's works...Borden's work is clear and limpid in style, and provides a both easily accessible and thoughtful introduction to the major periods and topics on Stein's work. It is a perfect work of reference, both by its structure and by its select biography and well-constructed index...the book is informative, concise, sober and helpful throughout.'
Volume 70, Issue 2
(Mette Lebech
Irish Theological Quarterly )
'Edith Stein is an example of a Christian thinker deeply engaged in the debates of her own day, and her work offers models and insights for addressing the questions of today.'
(
The Universe )
' Alasdair MacIntyre is one of the great names of contemporary philosophy.'
' this study provides much food for thought. It is not often that such an extraordinary life is illuminated by the thoughts of such an outstanding philosopher.'
(John Cottingham
Tablet, The )
'In this excellent new introduction, Professor Alasdair Macintyre, one of our foremost philosphers presents us with Edith the philosopher...This fine account, drawing on previously established biographies...is as good a summary of the events of this part of her life as you will find in English.
...Having just taught an undergraduate course on this subject I feel moved to include Edith in next year's course along with Wittenstein and Strawson...ultiamtely very enriching for the reader.
...[F]or anyone with a serious interest in Edith as philospher - or those with philosophical interests...this will be required reading.'
(Peter Tyler
Pastoral Review, The )
'This book gives a convincing account of what was "necessarily incomplete and one-sided" in Husserl's phenomenology, and of how Stein parted company with Husserl...attentive reading.'
Lucy Beckett, Church Times, 03/11/2006
(Lucy Beckett
Church Times )
"a dense book, requiring slow and careful reading...it opens the eyes to the interest of Stein's early work and its context within the still too obscure world of Continental philosophy."
(Raymind Edwards, Times Literary Supplement
Times Literary Supplement )
I warmly recommend this fine book to those educated common readers who want to delve deeper.
(
Catholic Herald )
"MacIntyre suceeds in making [Edith Stein's] work accessible and enormously interesting for the questions she raised."
Gavin D'Costa, Journal of Jewish Studies
(Gavin D'Costa, Journal of Jewish Studies )
Title mention in The Catholic Weekly, August 2007
"This is an important and gripping book"
Brett Gray, Theology, January 2008
'[MacIntyre] makes the philosophical disputes of the period accessible and relevant to our present concerns.' Mount Carmel
"In this excellent new introduction, Professor Alasdair MacIntyre, one of our foremost philosophers, presents us with Edith the philosopher from her earliest years, through her work with Husserl, finishing with her conversion to Catholicism in 1922. I found that the book seemed to work on three levels at once...This will be required reading."
-Peter Tyler,
Mount Carmel, July-Sept. 2010
"Among many other virtues of this study of Stein as thinker is MacIntyre's magnificent demonstration of how any philosopher must be situated in the context of where she studied, who her mentors were and the historical moment both inside and outside the academy. A bravo performance."
(,
Newsweek )
'...a comprehensive introduction to Edith Stein's works...Borden's work is clear and limpid in style, and provides a both easily accessible and thoughtful introduction to the major periods and topics on Stein's work. It is a perfect work of reference, both by its structure and by its select biography and well-constructed index...the book is informative, concise, sober and helpful throughout.'
Volume 70, Issue 2
(,
Irish Theological Quarterly )
' Alasdair MacIntyre is one of the great names of contemporary philosophy.'
' this study provides much food for thought. It is not often that such an extraordinary life is illuminated by the thoughts of such an outstanding philosopher.'
(,
Tablet, The )
'In this excellent new introduction, Professor Alasdair Macintyre, one of our foremost philosphers presents us with Edith the philosopher...This fine account, drawing on previously established biographies...is as good a summary of the events of this part of her life as you will find in English.
...Having just taught an undergraduate course on this subject I feel moved to include Edith in next year's course along with Wittenstein and Strawson...ultiamtely very enriching for the reader.
...[F]or anyone with a serious interest in Edith as philospher - or those with philosophical interests...this will be required reading.'
(,
Pastoral Review, The )
'This book gives a convincing account of what was "necessarily incomplete and one-sided" in Husserl's phenomenology, and of how Stein parted company with Husserl...attentive reading.'
Lucy Beckett, Church Times, 03/11/2006
(,
Church Times )
"a dense book, requiring slow and careful reading...it opens the eyes to the interest of Stein's early work and its context within the still too obscure world of Continental philosophy."
(,
Times Literary Supplement )
"MacIntyre suceeds in making [Edith Stein's] work accessible and enormously interesting for the questions she raised."
Gavin D'Costa, Journal of Jewish Studies
(, )
