I taught at this school for many years and I am familiar with the teachers and administrators the author has found necessary to criticize. I do not know the author because I retired in 2010, and this was before he was assigned there.
I saw virtually no comparative analysis of concerns that the author puts forth. For example, I did not see a comparison of graduation rates with other similar schools. Also, his examples of administrators and teachers that he apparently believes are not doing so well are the best that I have ever worked with. The principal is exceptional. She has done an extraordinary job, and neither the author nor I could come close to her dedication, ability, and performance. There is a vice principal the author describes in uncomplimentary terms that ought to be nominated for sainthood. She gives all she has to the school every day. There is also a teacher that the author describes feeding students because they use marijuana and are hungry. A lot of teachers have food in their room because many of these students do not get enough to eat. I have had students stuff food in their pockets to take home for the rest of the family. This has nothing to do with marijuana. The principal has a program to give students food for the weekend because they would otherwise go without. She does this, and more, because she cares deeply about these young people and their education. Many teachers spend a lot of their own money on food and other necessities, because the students need these things. It is hard to learn when you are hungry.
Frankly, I see a lot of complaining by the author and not very much as far as insight into where the problems actually lie. Did he just want to write a book to vent? Further, his inability to appreciate some of the best educators one could find anywhere is troubling. I would take the people he complains about over the author in a heartbeat. Forty-one years of experience should have produced more analysis, evaluation, and direction than I was able to see in this work.