Most Helpful Customer Reviews
22 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
In Captivity, July 25, 2009
This review is from: The Elephant Keeper (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
This lyrical and moving story explores the relationship of human to captive animal with a depth and intensity that makes it a must-read for any animal lover. The story is narrated by Tom Page who is well-launched on a career working with horses when his master buys two baby elephants, both ill from the long voyage to England. Tom devotedly nurses them back to health and at first all is well.
But as the male elephant reaches sexual maturity a change comes over his personality and he becomes harder to control. Also Tom's master finds the expense of feeding the elephants too much for his purse. First the male is sold to a distant nobleman. With a wrench of conscience, Tom Page chooses to stay with the more timid female, because he is afraid the head groom will maltreat her in his absence. When the female is sold, Tom faces an even greater wrench. Does he abandon his animal charge to stay with his sweetheart? Obviously, for the sake of the story, he does stays with the elephant that he has mentally dubbed Jenny, and thereby hangs the tale...
As the story progresses, the reader wonders who is keeping whom? Jenny the Elephant is a captivating character, holding her keeper by her side and the reader in thrall. Do the long conversations that Tom has with her represent real communication or are the the result of an internal monologue? Without Jenny, these thoughts would never occur to Tom.
This subtle historical novel opens around 1766 and the fictional events transpire as the American Revolution unfolds and Great Britain builds an empire. However, events in the larger world have little place in this story. Tom only mentions such things as touch directly upon him or his charges. This close focus gives the book unexpected depth. The moment I finished the book, I wanted to read it again. The author challenged me with his mode of ending it. On one hand, this seems to be a way of making the story less bleak, but on the other, it's risky for the author to inject himself into the narrative. Does this ending justify the author's means? I invite other animal lovers to read this excellent work with close attention and decide the answer for themselves.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
"But this IS a prison!", August 15, 2009
This review is from: The Elephant Keeper (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
'THE ELEPHANT KEEPER,' is a very unusual, animal driven, historical tale, evoking 18th century grandeur, as well as the sad reality of the Peasant class---those who were as much beasts-of-burden, as any other perceived sub-species. The chief protagonist is Tom Page, a groomsman's son, who becomes the caretaker of two elephants upon their arrival to Bristol, from the West Indies. The adventure chronicles their struggles, as they are moved from an environment of kindness and security, on an opulent estate, to situations tolerable only by the deep love and bond between them, that Tom refuses to break. The elephants', Timothy and Jenny, are clearly the stars in this relatively slow, and frequently sad read, making up for some moments of contrived and illogical plotting.
The writing, itself, is top notch, utilizing archaic terms and words, spattered throughout that set the time period adequately, while not being so overdone as to make the reading difficult, which is often the case. The settings are vividly described, without being wordy, and the characterization and personification of Jenny is superb. I suspect that every reader that ruminates about this novel, will think warmly of Jenny, first, even if they have grievances with the novel, as a whole.
Tom's bond with Jenny appears to be one of obsession and mental telepathy. They have some wonderful, humorous interactions, and, it is clear Jenny is a brilliant animal. But she also becomes the vehicle for Tom's unseemly fantasies and for projecting his undesirable feelings and emotions. This is where I began to have issues with Tom's development. Jenny appears to become Tom's conscience, as he struggles with good, over evil. At times, I thought he was on the brink of madness. There are elements of Tom's personality, when faced with increasing despair, that come in conflict with his earlier development, leading to some unsettling scenes, that just didn't fall into character, for this reader.
In spite of some reservations, I recommend this novel for anyone who has ever been fascinated by elephants. There is a wealth of information about this wonderful creature throughout this historical jaunt. It is also a good reminder, that humans and animals, alike, frequently share shackles. Tom was as much of a prisoner as his beloved elephants---his sacrifices, as great. The difference being, that Tom chose his role, the elephants weren't as fortunate.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
From singing prose, to false notes, August 7, 2009
This review is from: The Elephant Keeper (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
The Elephant Keeper starts out as a magnificent novel, then fizzles about 3/4ths of the way through, to become a dark depressing book with none of the joy and wonder of the first part.
Tom and Jenny the elephant are wonderful, as is Timothy, but when Timothy goes into his rut, and is eventually sold, things go downhill rapidly in Tom the keeper's life.
The parts which describe the elephants are fascinating and fun, but Tom the keeper as the `hero' of the book is flat. The nonsense about looking for his lost love, and then her not being what he wants her to be when he finally gets the nerve to go back home, is disjointed and absurd.
The beginning of the book is 5 stars, about 120 pages of sheer brilliance, which I could not put down. The ending of the book becomes luridly Victorian, about a 2 star.
Once again, here is an author with clear talent who makes a poor choice, and allows their narrative structure to get in the way of what they are really trying to communicate. If you love elephants, you will love this book if you read only the first part of it. But we know what will happen--no one lives forever, after all. It is just a question of how and when. The author tries to explain it, but the last section in the modern period makes the whole thing end with a whimper, not a bang.
All in all, I loved the first part of the book and am glad I read it. The writing there positively sings with joy and enthusiasm. The parts in London, I really could have done without, they are so discordant.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|