| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
A severe disappointment,
By BigD (Providence) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Elizabeth I, CEO: Strategic Lessons from the Leader Who Built an Empire (Hardcover)
I read Alan Axelrod's "Patton on Leadership" last year and found the book to be a witty, informative primer on management, so I naturally looked forward to this, the second installment in his opus. I couldn't have been more disappointed. This book seems to have been thrown together in such haste that it hardly seems to constitute more than the margin notes from "Patton." The prose is tedious and labored, and the information contained within it rather trite. I'm not an expert on English history of this period and at the very least, I figured I'd learn something on this front, but even as history the book fails. Its presentation is bland, confusing, and often seems rather sugar-coated. Most irritating to me of all, however, is that the book's title is somewhat misleading. The subtitle refers to "the leader who built an empire" but all throughout the book, Axelrod coyly dances around this issue without lucidly identifying what he's talking about. He refers to the enormous empire stretching from North America to India upon which "the sun never set," but this was in the 1800s; Queen Elizabeth died in 1603, and I was curious to know what part of the empire had been initiated at that point. Yet all throughout the book, all I got was confusion and frustration on this issue. I later dusted off my old history textbook from sophomore year and found out why: The Jamestown Settlement in 1607 (along with the Pilgrims about a decade later) was the first overseas colony the British even started, and the "empire-building" phase apparently didn't begin until Cromwell's Commonwealth period, about half a century later. So by the time the Queen's reign came to a close, England hadn't even begun settling, much less initiated the "building of an empire" (unless Ireland is considered to be the start of the "empire," which if anything was a case study in mismanagement-- perhaps why Axelrod conveniently glosses over it in this book). This especially ticked me off, because I felt as though I'd wasted a whole weekend reading this book. If you're interested in a book of this type, then read "Patton on Leadership"-- don't bother with the sequel.
14 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
First draw your conclusions - then plot the data.,
This review is from: Elizabeth I CEO: Strategic Lessons from the Leader Who Built an Empire (Audio Cassette)
Those who do not learn their history are doomed to repeat it, but those who learn it badly are doomed to write books about it. Elizabeth I is an amazing figure on the historical stage. She took a confused country and made a great nation out of it. Her guidance and tolerance in religious matters made her one of the greatest monarchs of all times. She was a woman on the throne at a time when most women could not hope to have their opinions taken seriously. In times of crisis she rallied her armies to defend the nation she ruled and despite much religious strife she earned the loyalty of both her protestant and catholic subjects. Alan Axelrod makes an attempt to carry forward her leadership secrets into wisdom we can all use today. Sadly, he seems to have written the book first and then filled in the blanks about the history. Each chapter Axelrod gives a quick overview of the topic to be covered and then gives the "leadership secret" followed by an anecdote to illustrate the point. Sounds good? Well in practice it falls flat. First problem was that there seems to not be enough secrets to go around so they repeat. Topics like `loyalty', `gratitude', `remember others', and 'be thankful' are all very much the same as Axelrod presents them and don't bear the amount of repetition that he gives them. Each time there is another anecdote but their aim is all the same. Another sticking point I, of course, the fact that some of the history is inconvenient and so has to be worked around. There is a point about avoiding playing favorites illustrated with Elizabeth having to execute her erstwhile favorite the earl of essex and how she learned the error of her ways and never did it again. In fact the reign of Elizabeth I is littered with her playing favorites most notably Robert Dudley. The blatant favor she showed him was a major factor in destabilizing her privy council on more than one occasion. The lesson on taking responsibility likewise falls flat. One example not given is how Elizabeth signed the death warrant for her cousin Mary Queen of Scots and the repudiated it as soon as she was executed. She threw some of her loyal servants in the tower for following her orders and wrote to all the European Monarchs to deny her responsibility. I wonder how that one never made it into the book. Many other facts of her reign are likewise skipped when they prove to be contrary to the author's intention. Her life and times were filled with many issues and problems unlike modern day. While there are many insights that can be gleaned from her life, they are not well presented in this book. There are a lot of great books on leadership in the market and lot of great books on history. This one is neither.
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Solid Advice with An Interesting Twist,
By
This review is from: Elizabeth I, CEO: Strategic Lessons from the Leader Who Built an Empire (Hardcover)
Managing a nation in the 16th century took stamina and skill for a leader of either sex during such a volatile period of exploration and conquest -- the time period also offers an excellent opportunity in which to examine successes and failures. Alan Axelrod's Elizabeth I, CEO is an interesting analysis of the strong management skills that Queen Bess brought to the task and developed in the process of ruling Britannia -- and he is adept at showing how we can apply such strengths to our own management approaches and develop new strengths, as well. Nice, too, that we can see what worked and what didn't work for Elizabeth I.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|