Most Helpful Customer Reviews
17 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A joy forever - Ellen and Austine, June 13, 2000
Back forty-something years ago Ellen Tebbits was the second book Beverly Cleary wrote. It told the story of an 8-year-old girl who basically has no best friends, wants a best friend, and gets one out of the "Californian" Austine Allen. Friendships like the one between Ellen and Austine (who happen to be in the same class, have the same woolen underwear problem, and also hate the pest Otis Spofford) are rare, and the two girls hold it strong for what should seem like a while. Even though they don't share some of the same characteristics - Austine would rather ride a horse then spend her time reading, Ellen's scared to death about them - they're still best friends. But unfortunately something DOES happen to this friendship, causing what Ellen feared for the most: the absolute silent treatment. For weeks these two former friends aren't speaking to each other. Could this friendship be saved? Will the eight year old girl who feared changing at ballet - until she met Austine - find a best friend in the spunky Californian again? Read and you might just find out. This book is certainly a joy forever, taking you back in time to the 1950s' where woolen underwear was just the world's greatest disappointment. Ellen thought this all - until she met Austine Allen, and things looked up.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
En Pointe, Ellen!, July 7, 2005
Ellen Tebbits is the only child of an overly fastidious mother who wants their home to look like a magazine layout. She laments not having friends and being forced to wear one-piece winter woolen underwear during the cold season. Otis Spofford is her nemesis, a funny bully who loves nothing more than to play jokes on Ellen. A big jokester, Otis' behavior seems more aimed at humor than malice. Otis' mother runs a ballet class over the Payless Drugstore and Ellen is one of her pupils. Ellen finally gets her wish for a friend. A husky, assertive girl named Austine moves into the neighborhood and the 3rd-graders are classmates. Otis is also in their class. They share similar interests, including walking past a garden with gnomes. (Kind of makes you think of George Harrison and Friar Park). The girls want to dress alike and even go so far as to pick out a fabric with red monkeys that they like. Ellen's mother is a seamstress and makes a very nice dress; Austine's mother can't sew to save her life and poor Austine looks like she got her dress out of the Rag Bag. This causes jealousy and a falling out. By the time the girls start fourth grade, Austine has snubbed Ellen until a chance to clear the air presents itself. Although this book was written in 1951, it is a timeless classic. The issues of friendship in the early grades and bullies and growing up have not changed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Best Friends, May 22, 2002
Beverly Cleary is one of the most celebrated authors for children in second through fifth grades - and for good reason! This book is from 1951 and a little bit dated, but the theme is clearly seen and timeless. Ellen is a sweet girl who is a little unsure of herself. She meets a wonderful person, Austine, who makes a friendship with her immediately. The girls become best friends and are very happy. However, as tends to happen with girls in fourth grade, they have a quarrel and are no longer speaking to each other. It takes each of them swallowing their pride to rekindle their friendship. This book serves as a great example of how friends should act with each other. Repeatedly, Austine is able to see the desires of her best friend and ask questions to bring attention to Ellen's show and tell, or divert attention to keep her from getting embarrassed. When they do have their argument, we see the pain that both of them felt and how they were able to save it with a simple apology and talking through what happened. Why 5 stars?:
Beverly Cleary has written many books that kids can really relate to. This one is no different as it teaches kids how to make friends, behave loyally towards them, and how to keep them. Moreover, it is entertaining and the theme, while clear, does not dominate due to careful writing. This belongs in the library of elementary classrooms, though it understandably would appeal to girls much more than boys.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
