13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent Erwitt Retrospective, June 12, 2004
This review is from: Elliot Erwitt Snaps (Paperback)
I really like Elliott Erwitt's photos, and his sense of humour. All my favourite Erwitt photos are included in this book, plus a whole bunch more enjoyable images. The photos are well laid out and the printing quality is very good. The only minor complaint I have is that a small number of photos are spread across two pages, and because the book is so damn thick, it's difficult to open the book fully and view these images properly.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Let Me Disagree, December 4, 2007
This review is from: Elliot Erwitt Snaps (Paperback)
Elliott Erwitt is among my favorite photographers, and it's really nice to have so many of his images, familiar and less-so, in one handy volume. But this book is not well designed. I'm at a loss how other reviewers could say that it is.
The book's format is distinctly vertical, and yet maybe half of its images are horizontal. For the vertical images, this book is great. But for the horizontal images, this book is a disaster: they are shrunk to fit the page width, and because they then take up less than half the book's page height, they are either stacked one on top of the other, to great distraction, or they are presented alone, at the top of the page, with an ocean of blank paper sitting below them.
Another reviewer has noted the poor performance of the book's spine to accommodate those occasional "full-size" horizontal images that split across the gutter. This is the bane of photo books. Publishers, please stop. Publish images flat, one per page, un-crowded, un-distracted. Given that Erwitt seems to not favor horizontal nor vertical, a square page design is called for.
At the top of this review, I noted how nice it was to have so many of Erwitt's images in one book. Yes, but let me also note that there are, in this rare case, too many. There is a lot of redundancy of similar images, with the second- and third-best of various sets displayed with equal weight as the obvious superior image. It pains me to say that, because usually I am complaining about the stingy number of images we're allowed to see.
And the text? Forget about it. Just drivel. Why are photo books so poorly written?
Nevertheless, all said and complaints duly lodged, I truly love Erwitt's view of the world. And it isn't just that his pictures are funny. Like any good verbal comedian, his stuff works so well because his craft is so expertly honed. His compositions are very tight, his lines are very straight, his timing is impeccable. For the price of this book, in terms of value, it deserves more than three stars. (And Erwitt, himself, gets an automatic five.) But some balance needs to be given to offset the grade inflation that I think is going on with the other fans of Erwitt, tossing around stars.
Buy it, enjoy it, but don't confuse five-star photography with a five-star book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No