9 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Disconcerting, unsettling and most horribly true, October 1, 2005
This review is from: Emergency Sex (and Other Desperate Measures) (Paperback)
The UN tried to punish the three authors of this book after it was published. Unfortunately the wirting was just too close to the bone for them, clearly, it is too much to think of instituting changes to their procedures. And when you read this book you can see why. It is in institutionalised bureaucracy, just like any other large amorphous institution. And its faults are writ large by Heidi, Andrew and Ken.
This is ultimately one of the most disturbing reads I have had all year. It covers these three UN workers through various postings all over the world including places like Cambodia, Mogadishu, Haiti and Rwanda - and the disturbing part is what they have to deal with both externally and internally from the UN. There are blood thirsty riots outside the compound gates, random shootings, sheer inertia, entrenched bureaucracy of endless futile filing and death, constant death and pain.
I didn't really like the style of writing, the story jumps between the three of them who contribute a page or so intermittently following a clear time frame of when they meet in Cambodia in the first free elections. At time the disjointedness of the telling I felt distracted from what was actually happening. This is also a very personal account and the authors don't set out to be personally likeable themselves at all times. It really is a warts and all.
Given the subject they have taken on, it is not surprising. The failure of the UN is very much in the people it uses to do its work, and that is at all levels, inertia and poor judgement stem from them and their implementation of the system. The problem is as deep and as wide as the people.
The shocking failure of the UN has meant terrible consequences for local populations - in Rwanda, and Haiti massacres occured. And while the UN did not cause it, they did not prevent it happening as they were supposed to do. Unfortunately I cannot imagine this bookwill have the effect it is meant to, that is highlight the problems and rally change. Here's hoping.
Disturbing reading
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Character study - trying too hard, August 16, 2006
This review is from: Emergency Sex (and Other Desperate Measures) (Paperback)
What motivates people to work in the humanitarian field is an interesting subject and these three different people demonstrate that remarkably well. You have the hard-working and likeable Kiwi doctor who genuinely cares, the idealistic American student and the self-serving person trying to find herself. Let me cut to the chase: Heidi was obviously the reason this book has its particular title. Her stories and motivation give humanitarian workers a bad name and it's thanks to people like her that the UN has developed a name as a money-spinning employer. Her self-described behaviour smacks of an inferior woman who needs to define herself through sex because she has nothing else going for her. Her exploitation of a number of young African men is appalling. This book would have been more interesting if it had focussed on the experience and almost jaded doctor, intertwined with the young American who is striving for knowledge and acceptance in this bizarre and draining world. Anyone can have sex in strange places, but these two men show that it takes a special sort of brain to survive observing some of the worst atrocities the world has seen.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No