1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Read the fine print - stamped is inferior to forged!, March 26, 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: Emerilware Emeril Cutlery Cook's Knife 5"
When I first tried this knife I was shocked at how dull it seemed compared to my old Wusthof knife (in fact I nearly cut myself when it slipped off my onion instead of slicing into it like my old knife would have). Thinking perhaps it was dull, I sharpened it (on a Chef's choice 3-stage diamond hone knife sharpener, a product I recommend), but there was no improvment. Then I did a little research and realized that the blade was made from stamped steel, not forged steel (the box it came on didn't mention this fact). Apparently this makes a HUGE difference. I don't know what Wusthof & Emeril were thinking trying to market a low-end stamped knife for mid-end or higher prices ($52 SRP?) -- Wusthof's high-end forged knives are excellent products, well worth the price (as are Henckel's forged knives). Pay the extra and get a forged knife instead.
Update: actually, there are some very good stamped knives out there, such as Kershaw Shun, but for manufacturers who make both stamped and forged the stamped seem to be cheap in quality as well as price.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
a cutlery essential, maybe?, January 1, 2004
This review is from: Emerilware Emeril Cutlery Cook's Knife 5"
although crafted in China for price lowering this little marvel is made from Wusthoff's fine Soligen steel. and while itappears flimsy, itis more than strong enough for its intended purpose: cutting meats,poultry, vegetables and fruit into nearly transparent slices. As received it was razor sharp.I tested my little 5" chef knife by slicing a red Globe grape into 50 transparent discs. the only other knivescapable ofthis are the outrageously expensive artisan produced Japanese laminated knives or Wusthoff's(or Henckels) imitations of a Japanese Santoku knife; all would be more versatile and larger, but expect to pay many times the minuscule outlay you'll make for thel;ittle 5" chef knife;
being much wider than utility knives, knuckles will not interfere with yourslicing . edge shaspness is long lived and mine has not needed sharpening in a year of regular use. I simply stroke it a few times on my fine cut steel to realign the cutting edge, althoughI still cannot feel thetelltale burr. When itwill need sharpening, I'll use my3000 grit water/ceramic Japanese stone: the steel good as it is does not justify final honing on my 8000 grit water stone but treated with the 3000 grit this knife will never require professional sharpening)usually on a wet grinder(onlythe most able of pros do not waste steel
to conclude: this diminutive"chef" knife is fine enough to slice fish for sushy and the handle will not absorb water or odors.while on the handle subject : it is perfectlytapered where it meets thesteel and pinching the taper between thumb andforefinger affords you perfect control.
One last admonition: never ever use any fine Kitchen knife on a glass cutting surface: glass is harder than ANY cutlery steel and will dull, even damagedamage your investment
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No