Most Helpful Customer Reviews
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
???, October 17, 2007
This review is from: Emily Ever After (Paperback)
Disappointing. (I must have a new edition, because my cover DOES mention this a christian book though.)
The plot is really weak and confusing - and I personaly don't know of any christians who would advocate preventing people with other opinions from publishing their essays! What next?
I remained frustrated until the end that the Brittany plotline was never followed up, and felt most of the secondary characters to be underdeveloped.
The student/young professional lifestyle is well described. And the absence of God in everyday life balanced by the occasional outbursts of moralism and choice of 2 or 3 stereotypical "causes" (no sex before marriage, drinking) as representive of what the christian should and shouldn't be like, is unfortunately an exact reflection of the typical "backslidden" city christian of today.
i.e. the priorities are all wrong - it's quite unfortunate that a whole chunk of christianity today apparently sees no sex no drink as the substance, rather than one of many symptoms of the christian life. It's no surprise that these people whose faith lacks depth (including Emily in the book) often find themselves playing with the borders.
It begs the question - have the authors got beyond that stage themselves?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Refreshing Chick-lit, August 30, 2005
This review is from: Emily Ever After (Paperback)
Like many reviewers, I was unaware of the part that Christinaity played in the book. I, myself, am a Christian and found the book refreshing, although a bit cliche. Although Christianity played a part, I didn't find it preachy. I thought it gave a honest look at the naivety that many Christians have. Other than that, it was standard chick-lit, except for no bad language or sex. It was a taste of old-fashioned refreshing that was enjoyable.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
One of these authors is pretty cool, the other's painful, August 7, 2007
This review is from: Emily Ever After (Paperback)
This book seemed slightly schizophrenic to me, and I kept wondering if the two authors split up the writing duties "I'll take the first half, you take the second."
The first half was a fun, lighthearted chick-lit story with a refreshingly nice, grounded heroine. It's similar to a book I enjoyed much more by these two authors, "The Book of Jane."
In the second half, let the moralizing and judging begin. We get harangues (from her friend) about how Emily's "values" are wrong because she drinks alcohol and even eats out in restaurants! To her credit, Emily does at least disagree with that, but the friend still plays the role of her conscience. Then, after bragging about how non-judgmental she is, Emily sneers at a friend who is dating a bartender. ("Appalling standards," she calls them). She doesn't know anything about this girl, mind you, other than that she is a bartender, not an "amazing" girl like Emily herself. What a shallow little snob.
Emily also (reluctantly) allows her parents to call her boyfriend's parents to check on the sleeping arrangements when she goes to stay in the family home for Thanksgiving! This is a college graduate! My parents are about as conservative as it gets but no way would they be interfering like that. This is the point at which Emily begins to seem like pious 12-year-old.
It all implodes in a frenzy of clueless self-righteousness (and I'm a Christian, mind you) when Emily makes "the right decision" to suppress a book whose ideas she doesn't agree with. The answer to "bad ideas" is "more ideas" -- if you don't agree with something, present your argument as to why. But given the way Emily's desperate squelching of ideas is presented as heroic, the finale seemed downright fascist.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|