Christopher Bram's EMINENT OUTLAWS covers roughly fifty years of writing by gay authors of fiction, poetry and plays that he believes changed America. In his introduction, Bram says that the book is not an "all-inclusive, definitive literary history" and that he is not objective. Works that he admires are often works that influenced him or that he feels a "kinship with." GoreVidal is central to the first half of the book while Edmund White dominates the second half. Beginning with the publication of THE CITY AND THE PILLAR, Bram traces Vidal's long life and career, his writing of MYRA BRECKINRIDGE, his essays, his very public fights with William F. Buckley, Truman Capote and White, suggesting that Vidal in old age has "suffered a hardening of intellectual arteries." Bram calls him "a godfather of gay literature in spite of himself--a fairy godfather." Edmund White, "a brilliant prose stylist," gets equal treatment: his early days in New York, his role as one of the founders of GMHC, his life in France, and the publication of his many books, both fiction and nonfiction. Bram also includes Truman Capote, Tennessee Williams, Allen Ginsberg, James Baldwin, Christopher Isherwood, Mart Crowley James Merrill, Edward Albee, Larry Kramer, Andrew Holleran, Armistead Maupin, Thom Gunn, Michael Cunningham, and Tony Kushner along with many other writers as well. The book begins with Part I, "Into the Fifties," followed by the sixties, seventies, eighties and the nineties and after. Mr. Bram also includes Notes and an exhaustive Selected Bibliography.
Although those of us alive when many of these men published their books or first staged their plays knew about them and sometimes read the novels or, less often, saw the plays, what makes this book so exciting is that it is, as the author acknowledges also in his introduction, the first time the stories of all these men have been told in one narrative. Additionally he includes quotations by straight reviewers of the works-- if they were even reviewed at all-- that were often vitriolic and mean-spirited so we see just have difficult it was for gay literature to flourish decades ago. Just one example from dozens: Philip Roth, who should have been ashamed of himself-- in not then, certainly now-- attacked Edward Albee's play TINY ALICE for "'its ghastly pansy rhetoric and repartee.'" This book then should be required reading for all of us, both older and younger gay men, who want a better understanding of how these writers, some of them very brave, helped to change America and our lives.
Mr. Bram includes biographical facts, his critical analyses, and trivia that all come together in a most readable treasure trove. After THE CITY AND THE PILLAR, the daily NEW YORK TIMES did not review any of Vidal's work for fifteen years. Upon moving to California in the fifties to write for the movies, Vidal discovered that hustlers only charged ten dollars before six o'clock, a good deal for him, since that was the time he preferred to have sex anyway. W. H. Auden didn't like Ginsberg's hugely successful book HOWL AND OTHER POEMS (that a federal judge in California-- who taught Sunday School -- found not to be obscene). But then he didn't like Walt Whitman either. James Baldwin wrote an essay in 1949 attacking Vidal's THE CITY AND THE PILLAR, arguing that it was not about "homosexual love" but "the fear of sex between men." Isherwood, on the other hand, wrote a letter to Vidal about the book, acknowledging that "many homosexuals are unhappy," but also reminding him that "homosexual relationships can be and frequently are happy." Craig Rodwell (a hero for me) opened the first gay bookstore in the country Oscar Wilde Memorial Bookshop in Greenwich Village in 1967.
The author writes extensively about the 1970's, that golden time in gay literature when times were so much better and exciting things were happening. In 1978, for example, three very important gay novels, FAGGOTS, DANCER FROM THE DANCE and TALES OF THE CITY were all published. (I remember buying all three from a local independent bookstore.) Then all the hell of the 1980's. On July 3, 1981 that ominous small article appeared in the NEW YORK TIMES about a rare skin cancer found in gay men. And Larry Kramer wrote his now famous and sad article in the NATIVE on March 14, 1983 about the number of reported cases of AIDS, "1,112 and Counting." Then he wrote his play THE NORMAL HEART that eventually was produced all over the country. Of course the play about AIDS that would capture the hearts of America in the 1990`s, sans one Andrew Sullivan, was Tony Kushner's ANGELS IN AMERICA in two parts. Part One won both the Pulitzer Prize and the Tony Award. Bram concludes this splendid book with a summary of how things have changed, from the overturn by Congress of "Don't Ask, Don't Tell," the states where same-sex marriage is legal, the publication of books by many young gay authors, the television drama "Glee," the mixing of gay and straight characters in "Six Feet Under." The list is long.
Even when I disagree sometimes with Mr. Bram's opinions, they are always refreshing and engaging . For example, he says DOWN THERE ON A VISIT "might be" his favorite book by Christopher Isherwood. I would certainly vote, however, for A SINGLE MAN, a novel I have read many times, and would argue that it is the best gay novel written in America. He prefers Michael Cunningham's A HOME AT THE END OF THE WORLD to THE HOURS. I would not. And I would vote for any of Armistead Maupin's TALES about San Francisco over THE NIGHT LISTENER. But isn't it wonderful that we have all these fantastic novels on which to disagree. He is so right though in his statement that "political activists rarely like fiction of any kind," as he says in his discussion of Craig Rodwell and Frank Kameny's distaste for "BOYS IN THE BAND." And while he offers no opinion on Christopher Isherwood's observation about those TALES that are much loved by gay readers all over the world that "'it is possible to commit art and entertainment in the same moment,'" I suspect he agrees with Mr. Isherwood.
EMINENT OUTLAWS is a book not to be missed.