Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Half-half, June 8, 2009
Undoubtedly the author is familiar with Roman and Persian history, but not Chinese. My reading pace was always interrupted when I found the differences between the history mentioned in the book and Chinese history in my mind.
"Da Qin" is how ancient Chinese called Rome. It mean "great Qin", implied that Rome was strong and civilized like the Qin Dynasty of China(221BC-207BC). The story said Prince Dan Qin explained "Da Qin" means "The West", this is not correct. There is another name for Rome "Hai Xi", which means "the west of the sea".
The story mentioned that China was in the three-kingdom period. If so, Han dynasty was already destroyed, there is no more prince of Han. One of the three kingdoms was "Shu", the emperor of Shu was a distant relative of Han's emperors, but not the heir of Han's royal family.
The Romans of the story were brought to Luo Yang - Capital of Han Dynasty, and the capital of the Kingdom of Wei, one of the kingdoms in the three-kingdom period. The emperior of Wei is not the same blood of Han, and the life or death of Wei's emperor has no relation with Dan Qin (The story mentioned Dan Qin's father died and the man named "Wei" kept the secret, implied that his father died in the city of Luo Yang).
[...]
I think this story somehow represents how an Italian views China - full of secrete societies and Ninja-like people playing Kungfu (although Ninjas are from Japan), and women are like Zhan Zi-Yi in Croching Tigers and Hidden Dragon.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting Speculation, Mediocre Execution, October 2, 2007
As a professional archaeologist, Manfredi must be aware of the growing body of evidence that many ancient civilizations had contacts with each other - notably the Celtic adventurers who traveled the Silk Road and settled in western China in pre-Roman times. But why populate a story about possible Roman/Chinese contacts with rigidly ethical and honorable Roman Imperial legionaires and near-superhuman martial arts secret societies, as well as a Han dynasty princess who throws away her privileged status for a newfound infatuation with a scruffy legion commander? The plot is reasonably well developed, considering protagonists with little credibility, including the supposed martial arts training for the princess and her brother. This promising speculation really deserved better execution than this somewhat juvenile effort.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Novel of Two Powerful Civilisations, October 3, 2006
Few authors can be better equipped to write about the history of ancient Greece and Rome than Valerio Massimo Manfredi. Professor of archaeology at the university of Milan, he has carried out many excavations and expeditions in the Mediterranean region. He has produced many factual books on historical matters, mainly military and has still found the time to write several novels and this is one of the best yet.
This book has a storyline that must surely be unique. It begins with the personal bodyguard of the Roman Emperor Publius Licinius Valerianus and their commander caught in a trap after Valerianus had agreed to meet his adversary, to negotiate peace and save the city of Edessa. However Marcus Metellus Aquila, legate of the Second Augusta Legion and his men manage to break free and find shelter at an oasis, where they meet a mysterious exiled prince. With nothing left for them the Romans agree to become the prince's private militia and volunteer to guide him back to his homeland., China.
While they are there they see things that no other European has ever seen. They see cruelty, violence, but on the other side they see men of great intelligence and tolerance and beautiful women, unlike any of the women in Rome. But everything is at stake, even the very survival of the world's two greatest empires . . .
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|