Customer Reviews

Encountering God: A Spiritual Journey from Bozeman to Banaras

5 star:		(10)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I had read and heard a lot about this book before actually buying and reading it. In eight closely reasoned, carefully explained chapters the author (a Harvard professor active in interreligious dialogue and open to any and all intelligent religious ideas) sets out the case for religious pluralism. She does this primarily by rational argument but also by personal and anecdotal narration, some recent history of interreligious dialogue, sound theological reflection, and sociological analysis.

In chapters subtitled The Meaning of God's Manyness and The Fire and Freedom of the Spirit she describes the many dimensions of humankind's connectedness to the transcendent and the variety of ways cultural differences assist us in our search for the absolute.

Her seventh chapter outlines in satisfying detail the three general attitudes members of a given religious community might hold toward those of other faiths: exclusivism, inclusivism, and pluralism. Pluralism is clearly the most desirable of the three, and she examines this stance by distinguishing it from other dispositions to which it bears a superficial resemblance but with which it should not be confused. Pluralism is not simply plurality or merely tolerance: it presupposes both. Nor is it relativism or syncretism. Eck emphasises the importance of interreligious dialogue, on which genuine pluralism is necessarily based and from which it flows.

In her final chapter the author shows why all this should make important differences in the way we live and interact with each other. This is a beautiful essay on religious praxis (not to be confused with practice) calling for radical changes in our minds and hearts (truth and value) that should enable all of us to live together creatively, with dignity, and in full appreciation of what it means to be human. This book can be recommended not only for those who profess a religious faith, but also, perhaps especially, for those who do not.

This book is likely to become a cult classic. It is a series of meditations at the same time it is a journal from the author's erstwhile journey of faith. Never abandoning her roots in Montana Methodism, Diana Eck follows the many paths of faith she finds at her feet. She steps forward always without fear and with a profound curiosity which she shares with her reader and with which she calls her reader to reexamine where they have been, and where they are and where they are going with the life that has been given to them.

The book is not preachy, but it is reverent. While the touchstone is Christianity, the author's own centering point, the scope is as all encompassing as the author's travels, geographically (Benarais, Japan, Europe, Australia, Boston, you name it) and spiritually (Buddhism, Hindi, Islam, shakti, you name it).

The Ms. Eck explores her personal journey in a completely inviting way to help the reader understand the profound threshhold at which the world's religions now find themselves. They can no longer be said to have an opportunity for dialogue, but an imperative to dialogue. We know each other too well and have too much to learn from each other to not share with each other. She shows us that while we need to speak in our own language of faith, we need to exert all the effort we can to hear people of other faiths in their language, and maybe we will then find them moving toward us or us moving toward them or us all moving to a new place.

The book is superbly organized, showing that Eck has used her years as a professor (and scholar) of comparative religion at Harvard to the best advantage. The Names of God, The Faces of God, The Breath of God, all provide frameworks in which she compares and contrasts the viewpoints of serious seekers from many, many faiths as they follow their hearts Home.

It is a wonderful guided tour for those who want to know more about other faiths. It is a compelling call to reflect on your own faith.

Two cautions: You may need to set aside extra time to work your way through this book. You are likely to find yourself, without warning, sitting in your favorite reading chair, not reading, but contemplating whatever.

Caution Number Two: This book might change your life. You may not be able to avoid the temptation to do something about what you have been contemplating.

Not to fear: You will be doing the right thing.

I read this book after returning from India, and have been kicking myself ever since for not reading it BEFORE my trip. Eck gets all the way around the fascinating but sometimes-puzzling religions of Hinduism and Buddhism in a way that makes them understandable and vibrantly real to a western audience. Her personal and theological reflections enabled me (an observant, American Christian) to look at these "strange" faiths and find God in them.

A hopeful and very personal account of Eck's interfaith journey interwoven with the larger global dynamics of an interfaith world that we are only beginning to fathom and put into perspective. The book deepened my understanding of how we must proceed to grow beyond these turbulent times. Eck explores her subject thoroughly and with great sensitivity. She leaves no misunderstanding about both the challenges and rewards of dialog, mutual respect, and understanding. I appreciated the quiet and reflective tone. Sip this book like a fine wine. It challenges and takes time to absorb, but is not academic.

Having lived in India for more than twenty two years after growing up Catholic and attending Catholic schools until I was a sophomore in college, I was deeply interested in Diana Eck's book. She didn't disappoint. Her commitment and depth of understanding of her own religion is not diminished, but rather strengthened, widened and deepened by her willingness to understanding the spirituality of India. Rarely have I read a book about experiences in India that combine such intelligence with such deep openness to the truth of spirituality in traditions not one's own. If the world had more such people in it, we might be closer to a unity of mankind whereby we widen ourselves to comprehend and benefit from the various ways God has manifested rather than circling the covered wagons to protect ourselves from any new ideas or experiences.

Very informational, especially about Hinduism. Rather harsh on Christianity, but you must keep in mind that the author is humbling her own religion with a goal of pluralism. Really feel like I learned a lot from this book. Definately recommend.

"Encountering God" is a fascinating travelogue of Diana Eck's journeys from the wilderness of Montana to the exotic beauty of India. Eck discusses big issues such as pluralism, fundamentalism, whether any one religion is true, using the context of her travels physical and spiritual. Her book is clearly geared towards seekers, those who say they're "spiritual, but not religious." She connects devotion to Our Lady of Guadalupe to that of fierce Kali. She sees unity in all things.

Religion is often a cause for division. In some countries, conversion to Christianity is forbidden. In other places, neo-pagans are stigmatized. If an Orthodox Jew becomes Christian, they're treated as if they're dead;Christians who become Jews are threatened with hellfire. Religion tends to represent the worst in humanity rather than its best, if one follows the evening news.

Diana Eck's vision in "Encountering God" sees religion as humanity's common ground, albeit with different perceptions. She parallels devotion to the child Krishna with that of the Infant Jesus. The butter thief and the baby in the manger are differing perspectives on the same reality. Still, Eck sees pluralism not so much as differences, but unity. She is more for pluralism than relativism. She speaks of respect for differences instead of syncretism. "Encountering God" is a tale of change... and challenge.

I discovered Encountering God in the library at New Melleray Abbey near Peosta, Iowa while on a meditation retreat. Diana Eck's story of being a twenty-year-old white Christian college girl living in the crowded city of Banaras, India on the banks of the sacred Ganges River drew me in immediately. As someone who lacks the courage for such adventure, her account allowed me to experience the Hindu culture of Banaras vicariously. There was not enough time to finish reading while at the monastery, so I bought a copy for myself when I got home.

The centerpiece of the book is her argument for religious and spiritual pluralism. She takes great scholarly care to lay out the problems with the alternatives to pluralism, namely religious exclusivity and religious inclusivity. Then she describes the importance of pluralism for peaceful coexistence of cultures and religions in our diverse world, quoting and relying on the teachings of Gandhi, Swami Vivekananda, Martin Luther King, John Hick, and many others. I came away wiser and almost totally in agreement with the author.

For students of Hinduism, students of comparative religions, lovers of India. Professor Eck writes a compelling story of personal faith. Highly, highly recommended.

Diana Eck's account of her experiences connecting with other faiths and her reflections on the multiplicity of human approaches to God is profound and inspiring. I ordered and read this book as a member of a struggling interfaith dialogue group. Eck's book is pointing the way for some new initiatives we plan to take.