From Booklist
The signed articles are sizable. The entry on Chaucer, for example, is some 14 pages, though most range from three to five. Most of the 118 contributors are professors, with a history of scholarship on their subjects, although there are librarians and independent scholars as well. Each article includes a section of biographical information, extensive literary analysis, some footnotes, and a bibliography including primary sources, modern editions, and annotated secondary sources. The articles are written in a scholarly but readable style. While the two volumes are alphabetically arranged, a complete name-title index in volume 2 leads to other mentions of the treated authors and their works, as well as names mentioned in the articles.
Overall, this is an impressive work. Though there are many treatments of British wit and humor, there are no comparable reference works. While most of these authors can be found in a variety of literary reference works, none has quite this focus on humor. The biographical information is interesting, but the set's value lies in the literary analysis of the elements of humor, wit, satire, and irony in the works of these 206 figures, as well as the inclusion of further references. Very appropriate for academic collections as well as large public libraries.
Review
"Libraries, especially academic and research libraries, should find this work useful." -- Choice
"This encyclopedia excels." -- Rettig on Reference
An impressive work, and while there are many treatments of British wit and humor, there are no comparable reference works....Very appropriate for academic collections as well as large public libraries.
Booklist/RBB
Both the analysis and the summary provide rich detail about the writer's humor...Recommended.
Library Journal
Both the analysis and the summary provide rich detail about the writers humor...Recommended.
Library Journal
Libraries, especially academic and research libraries, should find this work useful.
Choice
This encyclopedia excels.
Rettig on Reference
