13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Witty and DISinformative, January 6, 2008
This review is from: Encyclopedia Idiotica: History's Worst Decisions and the People Who Made Them (Hardcover)
If only things were that simple, as Stephen Weir suggests.
I really liked Weir's style and the format of the book, and the compilation is really well picked. However, much of it fell apart after I researched some of the "facts" presented by Weir.
The most egregious example is the origin of AIDS. A freelance journalist in 1990s came up with a "controversial" hypothese that AIDS was created because something went wrong with polio vaccination in 1950s. This theory has been discredited both by tracking the mutation history, which estimates that the first virii appeared between 1910 and 1930s with the accuracy of 95%, and by inspection of one of the original vials, where no signs of AIDS have been found. All this happened 5 years before the book was written, yet Weir dedicates a chapter to this as if it has been proven. These people, Mr. Weir, actually dedicated their lives to saving other people, how about at least double-checking the facts before presenting your misresearched verdict?
Another misrepresentation is depicting Churchill as a blood-thirsty and ignorant fool. Weir quotes him saying, "I do not understand the squeamishness in using poison gas on uncivilized tribes", without explaining that it was a tragic mistake on his part.
Some chapters are wholly based on urban legends or outdated myths: for example, that Moctezuma mistook Cortés for a deity.
There are also small things like announcing that general Nasser **defeated** the invaders in 1955. Earth to Weir: although in this case the big picture was drawn correctly, the military action was nothing but a very swift defeat for Egypt. Of course, Nasser was presented as a winner in the Arab world, but then, they still consider Yom Kippur War a victory, because they were winning for the first couple of days...
I have to admit, however, that Weir did a very good job covering the history of USSR, and especially the motives - which can be hard to figure out for a Westerner. A pity he didn't include Russia and, for example, the sale of Alaska.
This book's biggest virtue is that it provokes interest to history.
The biggest vice is that it is extremely unreliable.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Poorly researched, poorly written, poorly edited, January 8, 2007
This review is from: Encyclopedia Idiotica: History's Worst Decisions and the People Who Made Them (Hardcover)
I've read this book and found it to have many errors of fact. The basis of the humour depends on trust in the author that the historical accounts he describes are actually correct. Once you lose faith in the historical correctness of the book, as I did, it has nothing to offer, not even humour.
The author and publisher should have provided references for all the events described - the credibility of the book depends on it! If this author had made the effort to find and document references for all the facts, it would have been a much more interesting, satisfying -- and funny -- read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Enjoyable, light read, March 7, 2006
I love a good history book and I've read a few.
I quite enjoyed this one. Not as an introduction to things I didn't know about - I think there were only maybe 1 or 2 incidents in the whole book I didn't already know about, but as a piece of entertainment.
What I enjoyed was the author's insight into the events and the tale he spun around them. This is light entertainment reading, not a scholarly discussion. It is meant to to get people interested in history and to ignite our curiosity, not educate us about the whats, where, and whys.
Some of the reviewers of this book have criticised it's chocies. I don't think they 'get' this book. Weir's simplistic analysis and opinionated perspective are purposeful and I think they work well.
This book is entertainment and if you want a primer for some more serious research. And who wouldn't want something called an Idiotica on their bookshelves?
Pick it up, read it on your next holiday. You'll like it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No